Re:Logical Literacy
by astrofinch on Thursday October 14, 2010 @08:59PM
(#1793286)
OK, but has anyone managed to construct the real numbers with intuitionist logic? Maybe different logics are like different building materials, each with their own advantages and disadvantages.
> OK, but has anyone managed to construct the real numbers with intuitionist logic?
I think it should be possible to do so. As long as you don't need the law of the excluded middle you should be fine.
> Maybe different logics are like different building materials, each with their own advantages and disadvantages.
I see where you're coming from, but I think logic is more than just a tool.
More precisely, it is a model for human thought. The way logic is similar to UI is that logic's philosophical success is a function of how well human thought maps to it and how intuitive theorems in the logic are, just as UI's success is a function of how intuitive it is. The last hundred years of discourse on philosophical logic have been focused on one thing -- to formalize the human notion of implication better than material implication does. That's why logicians came up with non-classical logics of the modal, counterfactual (which captures the very intuitive notion of mutatis mutandis), fuzzy and intuitionistic varieties.