I am bringing up a very valid question and I'm not saying that I'm gonna do that, but if I was in PG's seat during the YC interview, that would be my question and I like to hear the founder's response because it is a valid concern and unfortunately a reality too.
For instance if Tapzilla can say to a developer that they have 20,000 users with an average 20% redemption rate then Tapzilla is going to be a lot more likely to be successful in selling their service to a developer than a new operation with only 50 users.
To be able to do this successfully on a longterm basis Tapzilla will need to be able to get several case studies as evidence that, due to the freebies, a certain App went up the sales charts which then resulted in more visibility and more paid sales. Otherwise it could just be a losing proposition for developers.
I hope PG did ask this question during the interview, so it should be easy to answer my inquisition.