News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mastodon and the challenges of abuse in a federated system by mschuster91 on Sunday September 02, 2018 @06:50AM (#17896511)
> Because shadow banning, for example, works. Having someone's voice lost while they don't know about it (keep living in their bubble) works.

Shadow banning is evil and intransparent. It may work, but at what cost?

Re:Mastodon and the challenges of abuse in a federated system by csydas on Sunday September 02, 2018 @10:27AM (#17897098)
Why evil? Or more specifically, why any more evil than any other form of punishment with regards to online communication? If one bans a user as opposed to just shadow ban, the end result is the user either gives up or just makes another account. In rare instances they reform, but usually it's not a reform, it's a change in methodology to avoid whatever condition got them banned in the first place. This isn't rehabilitation, it's learning not to get caught.

In either case, straight up ban or Shadow ban, someone is silenced as a punishment. In either case, the user likely isn't learning their lesson. In either case, the tools are ripe for abuse.

What is the exceptional cost of shadow bans besides them being opaque?

Re:Mastodon and the challenges of abuse in a federated system by lifthrasiir on Sunday September 02, 2018 @11:12AM (#17897250)
It is interesting for me that shadow banning can be evil (or not). Shadow banning is comparable to who hears bad words and ignores them, replying only with instinctive filler replies ("yeah", "hmm", "so?" and so on). Of course as a moderation measure shadow banning is a lot broader and more systematic than filler replies, but unless moderators do not disclose that shadow banning is in effect (without disclosing subjects), it doesn't seem to be a subject of moral judgement or whatever because any user can always choose to ignore you exactly in that fashion.
Re:Mastodon and the challenges of abuse in a federated system by dleslie on Sunday September 02, 2018 @12:34PM (#17897534)
I don't think that's a fair comparison; the one choosing to shadow ban another isn't simply choosing to ignore the target, they are choosing to disallow others from hearing what the target has to say, and in a way that does not allow the target an opportunity to change and improve themselves.
Re:Mastodon and the challenges of abuse in a federated system by com2kid on Sunday September 02, 2018 @07:01PM (#17899163)
> they are choosing to disallow others from hearing what the target has to say

HN allows you to turn on shadowbanned posts.

In the several years I've been here, I've seen maybe 3 or 4 shadow banned posts that were of value. In those cases, other users replied to the shadow banned user and told them to message the mods about getting the shadow ban lifted.

Heavy moderation of the tone of message works. In a similar vein, the neutral politics sub on reddit is successful because they ban people who are rude.

I think that if we moderated tone more often, that a lot of the toxic communities wouldn't even form.

Re:Mastodon and the challenges of abuse in a federated system by Fnoord on Sunday September 02, 2018 @01:10PM (#17897675)
E2E silent ignore does not work in online conversations where multiple people participate ("online group communication") because it meddles with the context since others do not participate. Try it for yourself: join an active IRC channel and ignore the first few people who chat. You won't be able to understand the conversation anymore. Spam filters work on 1:1 communication, targeted specifically at you. Shadow bans work on 1:1 communication and group communication if they're centralised or server-side. Its more akin to (SMTP) tarpits [1].

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tarpit_(networking)

Re:Mastodon and the challenges of abuse in a federated system by dleslie on Sunday September 02, 2018 @01:28PM (#17897757)
I've been using the IRC method since the early 90s; it works fine. Sure, there's some appearance of discontinuity but that's a feature, and allows one to personally guage whether the choice to exclude was a good one, without having to be exposed to the comments of the one ignored.

Shadowbans aren't akin to SMTP tarpits insofar as the target of force is less likely to be a bot. Behind the silence is a human being who is trying to engage others.

Re:Mastodon and the challenges of abuse in a federated system by Fnoord on Sunday September 02, 2018 @01:36PM (#17897795)
I've been using IRC since the early 90s as well, and it doesn't work "fine" when you ignore active members of a community who get quoted and such.

SMTP tarpits are like shadow bans because the perpetrator isn't informed about the ban/tarpit, and its meant to slow them down by wasting their time in their bubble that they are getting "work" done.

Re:Mastodon and the challenges of abuse in a federated system by dleslie on Sunday September 02, 2018 @02:07PM (#17897914)
If they're active members of the community that are regularly quoted then banning them is unlikely to be the best course of action; I prefer to publicly announce that I'm ignoring someone, and perhaps why, before I do. Banning active and valuable community members should, at least, be public and transparent, lest the community react negatively.

SMTP tarpits are more likely to involve a perpetrator who is operating a bot, and less likely a perpetrator who is personally engaged in the conversation and community.