Well, perhaps in the short term, yes, it does create artificial scarcity through regulation. However, if those barriers don't remain in place forever, you can have created a real competitor in those markets.
I find this argument somewhat like saying, without trying any sort of emotional appeal, only to create an analogy, that you shouldn't waste time protecting a baby or make any sacrifices for it. The baby doesn't do anything that adults can't (they already exist), and it simply diverts resources from the adults (dealing with temporary artificial scarcity). All true enough, if you don't concern yourself with the future.
Programmers that don't work at tech companies work somewhere else, investors that don't invest in tech companies invest in something else. So it's wrong to say that just because a country doesn't have any tech companies it's poorer, and that protectionism for tech companies will make it richer. (This insight, and the ideology it refutes - mercantilism - are 200 years old[1].)
> I see quite often asked Why does Europe not have tech giants? The easy answer is that they already exist and there is no way that small start-ups can fight them.
Germany alone has SoundCloud and SAP.
Yes, but maybe at a lower salary
> investors that don't invest in tech companies invest in something else
Maybe at a lower return. Countries that don't invest in high-growth sectors (which means high-tech) will over the long run have lower growth rates than ones that do.
> So it's wrong to say that just because a country doesn't have any tech companies it's poorer, and that protectionism for tech companies will make it richer.
When companies have a monopoly, they are able to generate an economic rent, which makes everyone except their shareholders poorer.
Furthermore there is the sovereignty argument: a country not in control over its information infrastructure isn't really independent.
So if a country can generate its own equivalents of Twitter, Facebook, Android, Google search, etc, there may well be a good case for it doing so.
I find it amusing that you'd mention these two in the same breath. I'm glad SoundCloud didn't go under, but it's not like it's all wine and roses over there [1].
There are several European unicorns in the last decade (Spotify and Adyen for example), if you wanted to focus on startups. Alternatively, if the focus is companies in Germany that hire software engineers like SAP does, there's always Siemens, multiple German financial industry firms, SUSE, and so on.
There is a national security component that you are missing. The day we do not needs borders for people, we will not need a border for data. But we are not there yet.
> “There is a strong feeling in many quarters that the reason that India has not been able to develop a Tencent or Baidu or Alibaba is because we have not been nuanced in our policies.”
This is very reasonable. Your country does NOT need a new Google or Tencent. Because they already exist. The only way India can develop its own companies is by creating an artificial scarcity thru regulation. I see quite often asked Why does Europe not have tech giants? The easy answer is that they already exist and there is no way that small start-ups can fight them.
This does not mean that to create that needs is good for the citizens. Maybe it is good that Europe depends on Google, Apple, etc than to try to create new local ones, as non-tech businesses can benefit early from their technology. But if the goal is to create your own tech giants, it is not possible when you are competing against well established cash-rich monopolistic companies.
> "They also warned that India has fewer legal protections than the United States against government searches and data requests, so private data stored in the country could more easily end up in the hands of the police." The central government has shown that it has very little interest in getting a good privacy law in place.
From my perspective, you may prefer that your data is in hands of another country, not even because they are more ethical but because they are just less interested in what you are doing. Local police in NewYork does not care what you are doing in New Delhi. So, the effect is the same. Your data may be safer in hands of people that have no political nor policial power over you.