"This rename() function is equivalent for regular files to that defined by the ISO C standard. Its inclusion here expands that definition to include actions on directories and specifies behavior when the new parameter names a file that already exists. That specification requires that the action of the function be atomic."
So to comply with the Single Unix specification, rename(2) must be atomic. The rename(2) function on OS X has been empirically shown to not be atomic. What reasonable conclusions can be drawn here?
What exactly are you arguing? What is your definition of unix? A label purchased from the Open Group or an implementation of a specification?
If it's the former, I completely agree with you, OS X is UNIX. If it's the latter, what standard of proof would it take to convince you otherwise?
One may feel comfortable claiming that OS X is "Unix" based on the fact that all versions of OS X since 10.5 have been "Open Brand UNIX 03 Registered Product" (from an archive of the Apple website), signifying that they have met the requirements for the SUSv3 and POSIX 1003.1 specification.
http://web.archive.org/web/20070823040630/http://www.apple.c...
http://www.unix.org/version3/
The Open Group owns the Unix trademark, which is what we're all referring to.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Open_Group
So I don't know what UNIX means to you, but where I come from, it's based on a certification that adheres to a defined set of standards.
What you posted is an unresolved bug report that doesn't prove or disprove that OS X is Unix certified.