News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Elon Musk's Solution for Dodger Stadium Traffic Is Full o... by stcredzero on Thursday August 30, 2018 @02:44PM (#17879525)
That's exactly the sort of logic that traditionally inflates tunnel infrastructure projects.
Re:Elon Musk's Solution for Dodger Stadium Traffic Is Full o... by takk309 on Thursday August 30, 2018 @02:49PM (#17879583)
How is it that the logic is flawed? There are real-world examples of undersized tunnels limited the growth of a subway network. London was specifically called out in the article.
Re:Elon Musk's Solution for Dodger Stadium Traffic Is Full o... by stcredzero on Thursday August 30, 2018 @04:21PM (#17880377)
How is it that the logic is flawed?

It's the exact opposite of YAGNI. It's attempting to build the ultimate end-all be-all up front. No wonder tunnel building is expensive, and all the projects wind up huge and bloated.

There are real-world examples of undersized tunnels limited the growth of a subway network. London was specifically called out in the article.

If a larger tunnel to Dodger stadium is needed, why couldn't it be dug below, with the old tunnel used to carry infrastructure for the new tunnel? That seems a solvable technical feat.

Re:Elon Musk's Solution for Dodger Stadium Traffic Is Full o... by discodave on Thursday August 30, 2018 @04:28PM (#17880446)
It sounds like you're trying to bring a software mindset to an infrastructure problem, which is somewhat laudable, but ultimately misguided in this instance.

In this instance, as others have pointed out, it's already clear that the Tunnel Elon is proposing doesn't carry enough passengers to make a dent in the transportation load for the stadium.

Re:Elon Musk's Solution for Dodger Stadium Traffic Is Full o... by stcredzero on Thursday August 30, 2018 @05:57PM (#17881159)
It sounds like you're trying to bring a software mindset to an infrastructure problem

It's more that I'm pointing out that the tunneling industry is stuck in a "tunnels are big, expensive, end-all be-all projects" which creates a self-fulfilling prophecy, precluding the development of radically cheaper tunneling technologies.

Re:Elon Musk's Solution for Dodger Stadium Traffic Is Full o... by jcranmer on Thursday August 30, 2018 @04:58PM (#17880699)
> It's the exact opposite of YAGNI. It's attempting to build the ultimate end-all be-all up front. No wonder tunnel building is expensive, and all the projects wind up huge and bloated.

The cost of making an incremental change to software is not appreciably different from incorporating the change in the first place. The same does not hold true for infrastructure; even a minor retrofit can end up being very expensive, especially if there was no provisioning for it. Look at the impact of the Rosslyn station on the DC Metro: the only practical solution to the capacity issue is to bore new Blue Line tunnels and a new underground station, which can't be had for less than ~$1 billion. Provisioning to solve this at the original system construction would have cost somewhere in the region of $300 million or so (there are other, much cheaper alternatives that can't be built with the current track geometry).

By saving $300 million, you're ultimately setting yourself to spend 3 times that much in the future.

> If a larger tunnel to Dodger stadium is needed, why couldn't it be dug below, with the old tunnel used to carry infrastructure for the new tunnel? That seems a solvable technical feat.

Undermining a tunnel is the easiest way to do this, but it requires closing the old tunnel to do. Digging a new tunnel immediately underneath an old tunnel is going to introduce different stresses on the old tunnel, which is going to be more of an issue if you're boring a parallel tunnel rather than a cross tunnel. Furthermore, all of the access points now have to go deeper to reach the new tunnel, which could introduce passenger circulation issues. It will also have passenger circulation issues during construction.

Maintaining access to existing infrastructure during construction is complex after all.

Re:Elon Musk's Solution for Dodger Stadium Traffic Is Full o... by stcredzero on Thursday August 30, 2018 @06:13PM (#17881272)
Digging a new tunnel immediately underneath an old tunnel is going to introduce different stresses on the old tunnel

So then dig the new tunnel beside it.

Maintaining access to existing infrastructure during construction is complex after all.

For many complex industries, there is innovation and cost reduction. Digging larger parallel tunnels is something that the industry should be making easier and cheaper, leveraging the existing infrastructure. The mindset that "tunneling is expensive" is exactly the kind of self-fulfilling prophecy which prevents such progress.

Re:Elon Musk's Solution for Dodger Stadium Traffic Is Full o... by jcranmer on Thursday August 30, 2018 @06:38PM (#17881419)
> So then dig the new tunnel beside it.

What if there are things in the way? Like... building foundations. Stations. Access to the first tunnel. Lots of stuff that might be reasonably expected to grow up in close proximity to a tunnel.

Digging two tunnels at once is going to be much cheaper and easier than digging one tunnel and then digging the second tunnel much later, especially if you never planned to dig the second tunnel.

Re:Elon Musk's Solution for Dodger Stadium Traffic Is Full o... by stcredzero on Thursday August 30, 2018 @10:10PM (#17882381)
What if there are things in the way? Like... building foundations.

Then dig deeper. Given the strategies talked about by Elon Musk, the original Boring Company tunnel would have been dug to avoid those in the first place.

Stations. Access to the first tunnel.

Those wouldn't have right of way problems.

Digging two tunnels at once is going to be much cheaper and easier than digging one tunnel and then digging the second tunnel much later, especially if you never planned to dig the second tunnel.

Therefore, the logic is to dig everything you might imagine you might need, ever. Therefore tunnels are always going to be super expensive and elaborate.

Re:Elon Musk's Solution for Dodger Stadium Traffic Is Full o... by jcranmer on Thursday August 30, 2018 @11:31PM (#17882722)
> Therefore, the logic is to dig everything you might imagine you might need, ever. Therefore tunnels are always going to be super expensive and elaborate.

Not everything you might imagine you might need, ever. But everything you can reasonably forecast to need in the next 50 years.

The thing about tunnels: tunnels aren't expensive, stations are (particularly the station mezzanines and the pedestrian circulation to reach them). A two-track subway line is only going to be ~30% more expensive than a one-track line, and a four-track line only ~50-60% more than a two-track line. And it doesn't take a genius to figure out which one you need: one-track lines are never a good idea, and four-track lines are only necessary for trunks in megacities. You can look at your demand and figure out if you're going to need to go to 8- or 10-car trains as your maximum train length. Not to mention that you also (as a city) have the ability to steer development to increase demand on your subway networks via tools like zoning.

Insisting that you have to build only to minimal, current demand scenarios is being penny-wise and pound-foolish.

Re:Elon Musk's Solution for Dodger Stadium Traffic Is Full o... by takk309 on Thursday August 30, 2018 @04:52PM (#17880643)
I am not familiar with the soil under LA but in many cases it gets much more expensive to "stack" tunnels. The construction of the upper tunnel relies on the stability of the soils underneath for support. Constructing a tunnel underneath may require the lower tunnel to be much stronger to support the loads. Why not just build the tunnel larger in the first place?

If Musk wants to construct these tunnels, that if fine but I feel that the City of LA would be foolish to allow him to do it without ensure that the tunnels can be used for larger vehicles if the "skate" concept proves to be inadequate. This would come at little extra expense and would still allow Musk to test his concept but have a contingency plan if it does not work.

Re:Elon Musk's Solution for Dodger Stadium Traffic Is Full o... by mcguire on Thursday August 30, 2018 @03:38PM (#17880021)
Logic is logic.
Re:Elon Musk's Solution for Dodger Stadium Traffic Is Full o... by stcredzero on Thursday August 30, 2018 @04:33PM (#17880486)
Not all logic is founded on a near optimal cost/benefit premise.