Re:A plea for lean software (1995) [pdf]
by bo1024 on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @09:22PM
(#17873457)
(Also to bdhess) just a note that I'm not trying to say the right thing for a car is also the right thing for software, just that the contrast between the design philosophies is funny (haha and/or peculiar).
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:A plea for lean software (1995) [pdf]
by emodendroket on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @09:40PM
(#17873533)
To be fair, you did argue that it would be nice if software engineers showed "craft," which suggests that you think the way software is done is the wrong way.
Re:A plea for lean software (1995) [pdf]
by bdhess on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @10:01PM
(#17873619)
I don't think there actually is a contrast in philosophies. The philosophies are the same for each: do a cost/benefit analysis, and then go with whatever makes the most money.
It just happens that the cost of fixing an automotive defect (i.e., with a recall) is generally way higher than the cost of fixing a software defect (i.e., by shipping an update). So the automotive industry invests more heavily in eliminating defects.
Re:A plea for lean software (1995) [pdf]
by emodendroket on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @11:18PM
(#17873888)
Certainly the philosophy when you're developing software for medical devices or rockets is more rigorous and careful, but the speed would be pretty much unacceptable for, say, Facebook.