This New York Times reporting on weight loss and metabolism is highly relevant: https://www.nytimes.com/2016/05/02/health/biggest-loser-weig...
The study within strongly suggests exactly what you're saying: massive weight loss results in a massive loss in metabolism. The difference in metabolism is on the order of hundreds of calories per day.
I've lost a combined 150 pounds throughout my life and I'm down 80 pounds from my max. I am not in the exact same situation as you but I feel close. I, too, limit my calories to roughly 1,600 a day.
I wish this topic was studied more and the science was settled. If the study is accurate, what is there to be done about it other than learning to live with a significant caloric deficit for the rest of our lives? This is an issue that potentially affects so many people yet is so rarely discussed. Thank you for sharing your experience.
But I've found, at least for me, that the temptation and the overindulgence is mostly tied to emotions. Not like "I'm sad, must eat," more like I'm looking to feel a little better in the moment so I just keep eating to feel that way until I come full circle and feel like shit again, now for a different reason. This has happened with all kinds of things in my life and I can usually trace it back to some kind of escapism.
I won't pretend to know what you're going through specifically but I've found that practicing the kind of restriction you describe - avoiding places that will have tempting food, keeping food out of your house - makes me think that I have no control, which is easily thwarted by just going to the store to show that I do. If, instead, I tell myself that I'm exerting control rather than the food attempting to, I feel empowered to make better choices based on all the reasons I know to be true (better quality of life, longer life, feeling better, etc). It's not the environment that needs examination and restriction, it's the compulsion.
Just my $0.02 ... thanks for sharing this. I'm in the middle some sweeping changes to address all of this so it's in the forefront of my mind. If you're interested, read a bit about conscious eating, that's helped me reframe my thoughts in a really positive way.
I realized I didn't have a hormonal or even psychiatric issue: I was an addict.
Addicted to sugar, fat, salt in extreme quantities. I would always go from a bowl to a box of cereal.
So I quit it all. Cold turkey. It could "fit my macros", but I took no sugar, no junk food, no snacks.
Only food. Real food.
And I realized it's really hard to become fat on rice, chicken and vegetables. You"d need an insane appetite.
And, after some time, I slowly regained control.
I stopped counting calories, and now I'm happy to say I'm able to eat half a Snickers bar and not crave anything else.
And I'm fit! Happy eating, keeping a bit of muscle and a low body fat =)
This I'd agree with. I'm addicted to food, but unfortunately there's no realistic way to quit food.
> And I realized it's really hard to become fat on rice, chicken and vegetables.
You are incorrect, in my experience.
One anecdotal contra-point for me - and this is going against popular scientific wisdom of calorie in vs calorie out is that simpler foods have allowed me to consume beyond the caloric limits. Recently I have been exploring this and my weight has remained in the 155lb range for over 2 months through vacations - I documented my findings in https://www.subu.io/post/176259843689/one-step-from-the-farm if you are interested! I am almost always feeling full and yet able to keep my weight stable. HTH!
So those long rides were really helping twice.
One way I deal with it is to stop feeling sorry for myself:
I follow Rob Jones - a double amputee who has now completed 31 marathons in 31 days:
https://www.robjonesjourney.com/documentaries/
He talks about the daily struggle you describe - and that's ontop of the struggle of having to learn to walk again; learning to do everything again; and putting your legs on ea. day when your body wants to reject them...
Basically, it really puts things in perspective and makes you thankful for the health you have left.
I respect your achievement in losing the weight and keeping it as well as still working on yourself, but I don't think life should be hard as you describe it.
Good luck.
> I can imagine sharing your story will lead to many people trying to offer you their ultimate solution
The irony.
If you're fainting, you're doing something wrong with your diet. You either getting too little from something, or too little.
I seriously hope this video can lead you to a better lifestyle. and sorry if I sounded too harsh, lowkey it's targeted to myself as motivation.
And I doubt too many people think it's easy - even losing a couple of pounds is a pain in the ass.
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/m/pubmed/22327054/
Chances are you are underestimating your intake, or overestimating how much you burn through exercise. I don't mean that as a personal critique: most people are terrible at that kind of estimation.
Can you link a study showing that <1600 calories is dangerously low? Or that a <1600 calorie diet will slow your metabolism?
Congratulations for keeping it off.
Losing weight is hard enough, but keeping it off year after year seems almost impossible.
I wonder what proportion of people who follow each diet have lost weight and kept it off for more than (say) 10 years.
If I had to pick one thing, it'd be my weight. I've lost 150lbs and have been keeping it off for years. People who've never lost a significant amount of weight (north of 50lbs) probably can't understand what it is like to have to fight your body every day of your life. I have to avoid temptation as much as possible, which means keeping only enough food in the house to survive for a week and avoiding social functions, among other things. If I know there's food somewhere nearby, I'll be distracted thinking about it until I either eat it or go somewhere else. I have to meticulously track my caloric intake and keep it under 1600/day average just to maintain, even with 6+ hours of the gym each week. They never tell you that part about losing weight, that the damage to your metabolism is already done and will never function normally again.
Do you have any idea what it is like to be compelled to eat? To be unable to stop yourself? to hate that you can't stop yourself? I'm going to guess not, it's awful. And you know what the worst part of it is? How easy everyone seems to think it is. Oh, you're having trouble with overeating? Here, let me parrot some bullshit clickbait nonsense from the internet.