Holodomor is literally Nazi propaganda.
Most historians agree that the Holodomor was not a genocide, just a famine.
Re:China’s Re-education Camps
by WillPostForFood on Thursday August 30, 2018 @12:10AM
(#17874030)
Why would you see something like that? Not only not true, but in defense of mass murder? I can’t even fathom the agenda - defense of Russia’s reputation?
Soviet history is very tricky subject to study.
Russian State aka Kiev’s Russia started in Ukraine, so saying Russia starved Ukraine is like saying USA starved California, if somehow California got independent and the rest of country blocked food stuffs.
> Russian State aka Kiev’s Russia started in Ukraine, so saying Russia starved Ukraine is like saying USA starved California, if somehow California got independent and the rest of country blocked food stuffs.
That's ridiculous, almost like saying World War II was a civil war between two Germanic tribes (the Germans and Anglo-Saxons) or between Roman ones (French, Spanish, and Italians). You can't honestly and accurately claim a modern union by pointing back at an ancient political union. You also have to account that many political unions, until recently, were empires, that dominated many distinct nations of people.
What do you mean not true? And no I'm not trying to defend Russia's reputation. Millions of non Ukrainian soviets also died in the famine.
Here is a wiki page with several different scholars positions. https://www.wikiwand.com/en/Holodomor_genocide_question
I'm pretty sure the upthread poster is saying (and I'm not endorsing every element of this, only my understanding of the message) that China is in the process of committing genocide against the Uighur population, and the “re-education” camps are a component of that operation with a thin pretext.
> A better example of the next tier is the gulags
The gulag was not, as whole, specifically targeted at resisters against an ethnic displacement policy targeting a particular ethnic group; it was a tool in political repression, but it wasn't narrowly targeted at repressing political resistance to policy targeting a particular ethnic group on the basis of core elements of the shared identity defining the ethnicity.
So, while both are manifestations of authoritarianism, they are arguably different in fairly critical ways as relates to the inference that I've it the other is part of a genocidal strategy.
OTOH, the gulag was, very early on, integral in the anti-kulakization effort that, while notionally targeting an economic class, apparently also had political and ethnic aspects and was arguably directly tied to a Soviet-directed genocide in Ukraine (the Holodomor), so I'm not sure, even if one accepts the analogy with the gulag, that's historically a justified argument against the camps being a leading sign of imminent genocide.