Re:Against Identity Politics
by stcredzero on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @03:38PM
(#17862156)
hell i'm an antifascist activist and im not a big fan of "idpol"
I observe that a number of antifascists have been documented to be into a form of "idpol" based on tribalism of subcultural affiliation of choice -- to the point where they are willing to do physical violence against people because they merely "seem" a certain way.
There are many affiliations which are not immutable, but which are very hard to change and closely held or prized. I don't think that people should be coerced to give those up. Perhaps the tearing of such identities of choice is only 70% as toxic as identity based on immutable characteristics, but 70% of awful is still pretty awful.
I observe that a number of antifascists have been documented to be into a form of "idpol" based on tribalism of subcultural affiliation of choice -- to the point where they are willing to do physical violence against people because they merely "seem" a certain way.
There are many affiliations which are not immutable, but which are very hard to change and closely held or prized. I don't think that people should be coerced to give those up. Perhaps the tearing of such identities of choice is only 70% as toxic as identity based on immutable characteristics, but 70% of awful is still pretty awful.
It's better to convince than to coerce.