News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Against Identity Politics by yourbandsucks on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @02:22PM (#17861383)
One of the biggest markers of ideological blindness is when people lose their ability to do basic arithmetic.

The United States is 65% white. How you gonna get to 51% of the vote when your primary message to white people is "check your privilege"? Bonus points when it's coming from a 25yo making $200k a year.

Re:Against Identity Politics by dragonwriter on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @05:02PM (#17862853)
> The United States is 65% white

Closer to 77%.

Oh, you meant non-Hispanic White.

> How you gonna get to 51% of the vote when your primary message to white people is "check your privilege"?

(1) US elections are often won with a plurality (and sometimes, e.g. 2016, simple minority) of the vote, 51% is not required.

(2) No major US political group has that as a major message.

Re:Against Identity Politics by yourbandsucks on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @05:16PM (#17862958)
Yes, I meant white as it's used in political demographics, rather than how it's written on the census form.

As far as the message.. one can send a message by omission. If you spend a lot of time pandering in a race-based manner to every group EXCEPT this one racial group.. some people might take that the wrong way. Especially if you've got a small, loud minority telling them to take it exactly that way.

My solution is to drop the race-gender-whatev based pandering and move to shared ideals. It's how democrats win. They lose at the tribal game every time. How you gonna wrangle 20 different identities against a single more cohesive identity that also outnumbers you?

Re:Against Identity Politics by ajross on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @02:37PM (#17861558)
Because half the population is women. Your arithmetic quip falls a little flat when you lose the ability to partition data along more than one axis. What was that about ideological blindness again?
Re:Against Identity Politics by yourbandsucks on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @02:42PM (#17861608)
Wanna get back to me with the % of white women who still voted for Trump despite all his comments and history?

It seems like your position is that "everyone gang up on white men" is a winning strategy because we've now sliced off a minority that doesn't get to 51%.

Ethics of that aside, it hasn't been working. Obama and Bill Clinton won on thinking and inclusiveness. Not on division and resentment.

Re:Against Identity Politics by dragonwriter on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @05:30PM (#17863077)
> Ethics of that aside, it hasn't been working. Obama and Bill Clinton won on thinking and inclusiveness.

Clinton and Obama received almost exactly the same criticism that you've made here of (presumably, you haven't actually named a target except by vague implication) current Democrats, by both those outside the party and some of their critics within the party. Sure, it wasn't well-founded, but it was no less well-founded than your criticism.

Re:Against Identity Politics by yourbandsucks on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @05:43PM (#17863169)
This thread is full of people defending and endorsing identity politics. The comment I'm replying to in this thread is a great example.

Obama in particular was very careful not to do that.

Re:Against Identity Politics by dragonwriter on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @05:46PM (#17863200)
> This thread is full of people defending and endorsing identity politics.

So were random conversations with Obama supporters.

> Obama in particular was very careful not to do that.

And yet, to the extent that is true, he was still charged with it by critics just like you, because plenty of people in his base did it, and so that was—to them—the primary message of Obama's party.

Of course, he was also a accused of doing it directly with his own statements, not just being the face of movement which did it, particularly after his “evolution” on LGBT rights during his first term, and also specifically in his speech addressing the killing of Trayvon Martin.

Re:Against Identity Politics by yourbandsucks on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @07:10PM (#17863734)
Man, you are comparing totally unfair attacks on Obama to totally fair attacks on rich 25yos who say ridiculous things about race and privilege without ever having any real hardship or responsibility in their lives.

I mean, you want to compare the Trayvon Martin story to stories of techies pitching a fit about the word "blacklist" in a codebase? That's the kind of thing I'm talking about, in case it wasn't clear. Can we not differentiate?

Re:Against Identity Politics by dragonwriter on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @08:10PM (#17864055)
> Man, you are comparing totally unfair attacks on Obama to totally fair attacks on rich 25yos who say ridiculous things about race and privilege without ever having any real hardship or responsibility in their lives.

This is incorrect on several levels.

But, most centrally, I'm saying people like the rich 20 year olds have been around forever, that people have been attacking the Democratic Party about them forever, they aren't a meaningful change from what has been around for decades, and your implicit claim that they are a change from Clinton and Obama is erroneous I. comparing fringe non-politicians that may seem locally significant in your social circles to career politicians who are also succesful Presidential candidates and being surprised that the former have a less carefully crafted political presentation for mass appeal, which is an unsurprising observation with no particular significance.

Re:Against Identity Politics by yourbandsucks on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @08:17PM (#17864090)
Poor 20something artists with far left views have been around forever.

25yos making 200k working for the man and then lecturing others who make less about privilege is pretty new.

I get what you're saying about singling out the dumbest individuals in a movement, but as techie liberals, I think we have an obligation to police. Just like principled conservatives vs their racists.

Re:Against Identity Politics by crooked-v on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @02:25PM (#17861407)
Who exactly is making that their "entire message" in politics?
Re:Against Identity Politics by yourbandsucks on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @02:27PM (#17861423)
I should have said "primary message". Edited, thanks.

That said, the primary message is basically the entire message in a world of soundbites.

Re:Against Identity Politics by mrguyorama on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @04:05PM (#17862380)
And yet you still haven't answered his question.

This[0] is the democratic party platform. Can you point to the portion that says "White people; Check your privilege"?

If you were not talking about the democratic party, as I've assumed you are, I'm sure you can find the party platform of the group you are referencing.

[0]: http://s3.amazonaws.com/uploads.democrats.org/Downloads/2016...

Re:Against Identity Politics by yourbandsucks on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @04:15PM (#17862458)
I'm talking about the social justice warriors who make up a disproportionate slice of tech community liberals. They're the loudest, their message is what gets through, especially when you've got people like Hannity and Limbaugh to help spread and 'interpret' their message[1].

Not about the broader democratic party, which very much includes me and many others who get annoyed as hell by the divisiveness of the above group. And I'm certainly not talking about the platform. If people voted based on that instead of media soundbites, we'd have a different country.

[1]: If you're a democrat, and you find that Hannity and Limbaugh are excited to quote you, please shut the fuck up immediately until you understand why they love you so much.

Re:Against Identity Politics by kevincrane on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @04:34PM (#17862610)
> social justice warriors

Never met an adult who's typed that nonironically.

Re:Against Identity Politics by yourbandsucks on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @04:45PM (#17862714)
And yet it does get said. And all sorts of people who would agree with the above-linked democratic platform voted against it.

Maybe there's a messaging problem, and maybe the people I'm grossly offending in this thread are part of it. If they can't handle liberal techie me without being triggered, how could they possibly converse with Joe Sixpack?

Re:Against Identity Politics by colemickens on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @06:01PM (#17863317)
"triggered". Really though? The only people that ever use "triggered" and "social justice warriors" non-ironically are trolls and people with despicable enough views that we don't bother talking about or engaging with them.

The fact that you're trying to act like there are a group of Democrats that actively, universally hate white people and proudly call themselves "sjw" is destroying any remaining credibility you have. It's also just painfully embarrassing to watch happen.

Re:Against Identity Politics by yourbandsucks on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @06:14PM (#17863412)
You gotta update your lexicon bro. There's a new generation and they even say micro aggression.

These people exist and they are huge in silicon valley. God bless ya if you haven't encountered them.

Re:Against Identity Politics by colemickens on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @05:58PM (#17863303)
I haven't cringed so much at a set of HN comments as I have today.

"Check your privilege" isn't a phrase that anyone seriously uses. Do you deny that privilege exists? Do you think that the only people who talk about privilege are non-white? Do you think that the concept of privilege makes all white people evil, or is a message that is un-hearable to all white people?

You just showed more about your own biases than you did anything to advance any conversation here. Then you double down further in the thread about "Social justice warriors" being a real thing (it's literally only ever used as a boogeyman by people with really broken, wrong thoughts about "privilege" as an abstract concept, so thanks for confirming that I guess.)

It's not even a "primary" message. What politician advanced that message recently? Which politically-affiliated political action group has "check your privilege" as a mantra? And here I am, again, pushing someone for evidence when it's painfully obvious that there's nothing there other than unsupported biases.

Re:Against Identity Politics by toasterlovin on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @06:13PM (#17863405)
FWIW, I live in Portland, OR and there are billboards up in town here with this text:

"Portland, is your white fragility showing?"

https://www.wweek.com/news/2018/04/24/in-true-portland-style...

Re:Against Identity Politics by yourbandsucks on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @06:07PM (#17863366)
A year ago I would have made this exact same comment. But here we are. All depends on who you're exposed to, I guess.

Could you be a little more specific about what my thoughts are on privilege as an abstract concept? I've been wanting someone to tell me about that.

Re:Against Identity Politics by colemickens on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @06:15PM (#17863414)
Your own comment where you brought up privilege do plenty to demonstrate how you think about it. The fact that you compare the percentage of white people and act like "check your privilege" is a perfect opposite of "whiteness", I mean, maybe you have another interpretation of what you meant...
Re:Against Identity Politics by yourbandsucks on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @06:17PM (#17863432)
No, no, you keep going. You're doing great.

How did my childhood impact these views?

Re:Against Identity Politics by colemickens on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @06:18PM (#17863439)
You made the comment that we can all still read. You could choose to justify it. Instead, like every single conservative troll on every social media platform ever, you've decided to just troll your way down to the bottom. Have fun, it'll be by yourself.
Re:Against Identity Politics by yourbandsucks on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @06:22PM (#17863467)
Real talk: I'm a lifelong progressive who's very willing to trade my own purity in order to WIN. You're being sanctimonious and not graceful about being called on it.

Assume good intentions.

I've been around a lot of younger people who actually unironically say this stuff lately. No joke. Ask others on the board working at SV-based companies hiring out of college.