News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Black Design – Design tools for early stage startup founders by bobbygoodlatte on Monday August 27, 2018 @06:24PM (#17855066)
I think the strongest Product Designers wind up taking on responsibilities that PM's might traditionally hold (and vice versa).

I'm fairly biased here, but I'd argue that product vision is often best executed in the hands of product designers rather than PMs. Having a design leader who takes the product or feature from high level goals, to flows & interactions, and finally down to the pixels often leads to a less-compromised end result. I usually find that singular vision beats design-by-committee.

Of course, this rarely happens due to company politics, which PMs tend to excel at versus designers.

Re:Black Design – Design tools for early stage startup founders by hbosch on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @01:46AM (#17856789)
As much as I want this to be true, there is (in my experience) an observable difference between product designers and product managers when it comes to understanding technical and business problems... especially in communicating with engineers.

As egotistical and tyrannical as PMs can sometimes be, I have learned to appreciate their function... however, they love to believe that they are miniature CEOs which is hilarious and incredibly annoying at the same time. Designers in lead roles don’t seem to have this problem. Maybe it comes with the MBA.

Re:Black Design – Design tools for early stage startup founders by ASpring on Monday August 27, 2018 @06:39PM (#17855133)
I agree with this but with a strong caveat. I believe product designers excel in B2C applications but aren't often as successful in B2B and Enterprise focused applications.