The 2007-09 "bear market...lasted from October 9th 2007 to March 9th 2009" [1]. Using the same data as before [2] we find similarly-paltry 2.2% annualized wage growth between October 2007 and October 2017 [a].
Your counterargument is not only inaccurate, it also makes no sense. My argument relies on the former number being smaller than the latter. Picking a low baseline presents my evidence in its most conservative form.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_bear_market_of_2...
[2] https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/CES0500000003
[a] (26.47 / 21.06) ^ (1 / 10) - 1
Comparing down is not helpful. The government is supposed to be striving up and not letting things settle compared to a low baseline or slide down.
If you're arguing that the situation is within bounds of some sort of cycle or variance, you get to show evidence for bounded variance (e.g. bands) and arguments on how much of it is normal.
My argument was that wage growth in the last few months has been significant; before that it was insignificant. So yes, the average American is earning more (in real terms) than in the 1800s, 1950s or even mid-2000s. But that wasn’t the argument.