Re:Thorium power has a protactinium problem
by mdorazio on Sunday August 26, 2018 @11:40AM
(#17846380)
Thanks for this summary. Personally, I think at some point we're going to have to accept that non-proliferation is kind of a lost cause. We're rapidly approaching a time when anyone with some spare time and internet access can start CRISPRing a new plague or fly a drone spewing sarin above a crowd of people. Going to great lengths to cripple power production to prevent the production of some fissile material is like plugging a leak in your boat when there are multiple torpedoes about to hit. If you can go from some U-233 to a working weapon capable of threatening other nations, there are probably other avenues available to you as well.
Re:Thorium power has a protactinium problem
by acidburnNSA on Sunday August 26, 2018 @11:48AM
(#17846402)
Fully agreed. And it's usually much easier to just get some high-speed centrifuges and enrich uranium and make a very simple gun-type nuclear bomb. This requires no nuclear reactor whatsoever and will not go away if we ban nuclear reactors.
Re:Thorium power has a protactinium problem
by angry_octet on Monday August 27, 2018 @08:07AM
(#17850912)
Well, it takes lots of electricity and a cascade of hundreds of ultra high speed (2kHz) centrifuges full of ultra corrosive, poisonous uranium hexafluoride.
'Just getting' some of these is the story of modern proliferation, the theft of the tech specs from Europe by AQ Khan, and his/Pakistan's subsequent proliferation to Iran, Libra and North Korea. Because without good centrifuges, the SWU (separation work) per electrical energy is very poor -- more than 100 times more energy.
Re:Thorium power has a protactinium problem
by acidburnNSA on Monday August 27, 2018 @09:38AM
(#17851405)
That's why Silex technology (laser isotopic enrichment) is the only privately held information that is classified by the US government [1]. It can bring energy needs down by a lot, with a much smaller footprint.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Separation_of_isotopes_by_lase...
Re:Thorium power has a protactinium problem
by canhascodez on Sunday August 26, 2018 @11:26AM
(#17846316)
> I'm a huge proponent of nuclear reactors but I have yet to see a design that is truly proliferation-proof.
I assume this statement is limited to nuclear power generation? You wouldn't extend that to, say, that one Iraqi research reactor?
Re:Thorium power has a protactinium problem
by acidburnNSA on Sunday August 26, 2018 @11:50AM
(#17846410)
Yeah I'm mostly referring to engaging them in their unique ability to make 24/7 clean and low-footprint energy. I don't support using them for making nuclear weapons.
Countermeasures are to make sure there's some U-238 around to blend it down (but then it makes Plutonium and minor actinides), use faster neutrons (not as affected by the Pa), or install safeguards around the reactor.
I'm a huge proponent of nuclear reactors but I have yet to see a design that is truly proliferation-proof. All reactors require safeguards. It's still well worth getting that low-footprint 24/7 clean energy, which nukes alone can produce.
Thorium is great. It doesn't automatically solve all issues in nuclear. Here are the highlights of modern common Thorium Misconceptions: https://whatisnuclear.com/thorium-myths.html