News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Thorium power has a protactinium problem by ohazi on Sunday August 26, 2018 @02:02AM (#17844517)
I thought the real problem with Thorium is that salt eventually corrodes just about everything, which makes building a reactor that uses molten radioactive salt a bit of a sketchy long-term proposition.
Re:Thorium power has a protactinium problem by nickik on Sunday August 26, 2018 @03:31AM (#17844754)
The primary problem for a Breeder is actually that it corrodes the graphite. We have the metals that are corrosion resistant for long enough.

The primary problem with the metal is actually just qualifying that it is actually the case. The material they used in the original Molten Salt Experiment was great at resistance but re-qualifying this (or anything) to modern standards is incredibly difficult.

The 'Stable Salt Reactor' for Moltex actually have a solution where they use a slightly different salt that they can put some metal into and the chemistry works out that it will corrode that metal first and the piping is fine.

I however primary believe that for the last 40 years, regulatory approve and path to market were the primary issues. In the molten salt reactor experiment they solved many of these problems in relatively short time with a tiny team of people.

Because of regulations you basically can not develop a test reactor, and all of the nuclear companies basically design directly to production because it would be way to expensive to build a test reactor. Building a tiny research reactor would be an option, but those are limited to sizes that are to small to actually validate your design.

Re:Thorium power has a protactinium problem by danmaz74 on Sunday August 26, 2018 @06:18AM (#17845202)
> The material they used in the original Molten Salt Experiment was great at resistance but re-qualifying this (or anything) to modern standards is incredibly difficult.

Care to elaborate? Looks like a very interesting problem.

Re:Thorium power has a protactinium problem by nickik on Sunday August 26, 2018 @08:43AM (#17845693)
I am not very knowledge about nuclear material qualification, I can just tell you what I have heard.

The material they developed for the MSR was called Hastelloy N and showed a lot of promise.

Sadly, because its primary benefit was working with salts, it was not further developed and the use it saw does not qualify it for use in a modern nuclear reactor.

Therefore you have to do a complete re-qualification of the material under advanced neutron flux. Nuclear regulations are so incredibly strict that doing that alone would probably blow most development timelines.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Molten-Salt_Reactor_Experiment...

Re:Thorium power has a protactinium problem by j9461701 on Sunday August 26, 2018 @09:08AM (#17845773)
The original experimental reactor didn't go all the way and test the reactor design in a "closed loop". As in you shovel in thorium and get out power indefinitely. Instead it relied on temporary uranium fuel as a test of the concept, with plans to step up to a full cycle test afterward (which never happened as the navy lost interest in the project).

So not just regulations are at issue. We'd need a 2nd test reactor to really iron out the kinks and fully vet the whole process in real life, and then we can start getting approval for commercial plants. As I've said elsewhere, thorium reactors are very exciting and we should be funding experiments on them. But we are still at the 'funding experiments' phase of this endeavor, and so even at peak funding we're still a ways out from viable thorium grid power.

Re:Thorium power has a protactinium problem by nickik on Sunday August 26, 2018 @09:16AM (#17845800)
The problem is that you can't say that 'the regulations are not the issue' because its regulation that prevent all research in that direction.

The way the regulation works at the moment makes building a test reactor basically impossible for a company to do that's why pretty much every single nuclear company produces directly to a production model.

Thorium breeding was proven, but not in the MSR. So that does not necessarily need validation.

The 2-fluid reactor design would need a test reactor, but there are other reactor designs, like the IMSR that really would not need much further research.

However, if you don't go to a fuel breeder with online refueling thorium does not buy you much. Uranium is fine and does everything you want and that's why most MSR companies use Uranium.

Re:Thorium power has a protactinium problem by tim333 on Sunday August 26, 2018 @06:44AM (#17845278)
I think the real problem with Thorium from a practical point of view is cost effectiveness. Having to develop a bunch of new technology and reprocess red hot fuel is probably going to work out considerably more expensive just building a conventional reactor which itself is looking like being more expensive than renewables.
Re:Thorium power has a protactinium problem by baybal2 on Sunday August 26, 2018 @02:22AM (#17844567)
How big it is of a problem? Sodium alloys do the same, if not worse, but industry had metallurgy solutions to deal with it for last 50 years.
Re:Thorium power has a protactinium problem by ohazi on Sunday August 26, 2018 @03:11AM (#17844707)
My understanding of the situation is that corrosion is the main issue holding back Thorium reactor design.

Molten sodium is used in the coolant loop of some fast reactors, but it doesn't develop any long-lived radioactive byproducts, so it (and the various parts and fittings that it inevitably corrodes) can be disposed of relatively easily. They don't really have solutions to keep it contained, it eventually eats through everything. You just have to keep it from contacting water and exploding.

Re:Thorium power has a protactinium problem by nickik on Sunday August 26, 2018 @08:50AM (#17845709)
Corrosion is by far not the main issue holding back Thorium reactors. In fact in the MSR experiment they did a lot of work on corrosion and they considered it very solvable.

Re-qualifying that material would be tricky and costly, but there are companies doing it.

For the MSR style modern 2 fluid reactor your main problem is the chemical plant that needs to live in the reactor itself.

Secondly Thorium has absolutely no regularly support, and given the way nuclear regulation works its basically impossible to get a new fuel and type of reactor to market.

There is Thorium fuel for LWR coming to the market very slowly, but the advantages of that are very limited.

Re:Thorium power has a protactinium problem by angry_octet on Monday August 27, 2018 @08:14AM (#17850933)
I thought the combination:

- hot corrosive sodium

- heat exchanged with water for steam turbine

- water+sodium = boom

was always going to be problematic.