Re:Set Theory and Algebra in CS: Introduction to Mathematica...
by antidesitter on Saturday August 25, 2018 @05:50PM
(#17842761)
> I think Cantor’s set theory and everything that flows from it is a bunch of hokum.
Why?
Re:Set Theory and Algebra in CS: Introduction to Mathematica...
by jacobolus on Saturday August 25, 2018 @05:55PM
(#17842786)
In my opinion it is entirely speculative, built on largely unconvincing foundations (involving a lot of hand waving and circular reasoning when you start poking at them) whose implications are often absurd.
But it doesn’t really matter what I think. This is not a fight I care about. It’s like arguing with Buddhists about the nature of suffering or something.
YMMV.
Re:Set Theory and Algebra in CS: Introduction to Mathematica...
by bordercases on Saturday August 25, 2018 @07:46PM
(#17843243)
Are you more comfortable with a different set of foundations? Intuitionistic? Finitistic or non-completable infinities?
Re:Set Theory and Algebra in CS: Introduction to Mathematica...
by antidesitter on Sunday August 26, 2018 @12:20AM
(#17844238)
Can a statement like Goodstein's theorem (which is about finite objects) be proven by finitist mathematics? It cannot be proven by Peano arithmetic, which is bi-interpretable with ZFC with the axiom of infinity replaced by its negation [1], or any weaker theory.
[1] https://math.stackexchange.com/questions/315399/how-does-zfc...
Re:Set Theory and Algebra in CS: Introduction to Mathematica...
by throwawaymath on Saturday August 25, 2018 @08:39PM
(#17843484)
Could you expand on this a little? Which reasoning do you find to be circular and which implications to you find to be absurd? If you explain what you an issue with others may be able to help you understand it more clearly.
Re:Set Theory and Algebra in CS: Introduction to Mathematica...
by antidesitter on Sunday August 26, 2018 @12:10AM
(#17844208)
What does "speculative" and "unconvincing" mean, in the context of a mathematical theory?
What do you find hand-wavy or circular about it?
Can you specify which absurd implications you're referring to?
Not trying to argue, just genuinely curious.
But if mathematicians’ convention is that they will refer to ZFC when writing their proofs about something else I am interested in, I am willing to humor them, and keep my caveats to myself.
I’m reasonably well convinced that most models mathematicians can make in the context of ZFC which have any real-world implications (e.g. accurately simulate some physical phenomenon) could be alternately proved under some more restrictive set of axioms, just sometimes with a lot more hassle.