News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Paradox of Karl Popper by raverbashing on Saturday August 25, 2018 @02:42PM (#17841950)
> Scientists were reproducing each others work before statistics was a thing

They were also doing that before Popper was a thing.

> Whatever "statistical can of worms" there is regarding it sounds like a problem with the statistics being used rather than science.

Not really. It's easier to prove "Drug X cures dying from disease Y 99% of the time" than "Drug X solves issue Y 30% of the time only in individuals with a certain combination of characteristics".

Re:The Paradox of Karl Popper by nonbel on Saturday August 25, 2018 @03:06PM (#17842052)
> Scientists were reproducing each others work before statistics was a thing

They were also doing that before Popper was a thing.

Yes, but not sure why you are pointing that out.

> Whatever "statistical can of worms" there is regarding it sounds like a problem with the statistics being used rather than science.

Not really. It's easier to prove "Drug X cures dying from disease Y 99% of the time" than "Drug X solves issue Y 30% of the time only in individuals with a certain combination of characteristics".

If you had a complete understanding you would only apply the drug when it would work and have 100% success rate.

Re:The Paradox of Karl Popper by raverbashing on Saturday August 25, 2018 @04:19PM (#17842393)
> If you had a complete understanding you would only apply the drug when it would work and have 100% success rate.

There is no way to have 100% understanding of a specific person to have a designer drug for every condition.

Not even Aspirin is 100% effective nor we have a complete understanding of how it works (though there were some discoveries on that regard around 20yrs ago, I think)

It's hard for physics and it's impossible for biology (and other fields) to come up with completely accurate predictions.

Re:The Paradox of Karl Popper by nonbel on Saturday August 25, 2018 @04:23PM (#17842408)
Designing reproducible experiments and making accurate predictions are both important, but they are totally different things. Somehow you've combined them into one concept.