401(k)'s history is almost wacky. It was an obscure provision in 1978 tax law and a benefits consultant figured out a way to turn it into something that companies could easily offer to employees as a tax-advantaged benefit.
Of course, once a benefit becomes the norm, it's almost impossible for individual firms to not offer it.
You do additionally have a personal option, IRAs, that you can establish at the broker of your choice that give you a lot more flexibility. You can probably setup payroll auto-deduction in many cases.
I am surprised that post enron that US pensions where not reformed.
Defined benefit pensions are different and are much less common than they used to be. So mostly they have been reformed by ceasing to exist in the US. There are various protections for pensions but they're still an issue--especially in municipalities with financial issues.
ADDED: And there's actually a lot of sensitivity these days to 401(k) options that are perceived as risky. Such as a company's own stock.
Someone always needs to bear the risk that the planned payout will be less than forecast. Whether it's the employee or the company. And, at some point, if the money's not there it won't be paid out.
It was illegal for them to offer more money - Roosevelt instituted wage fixing. Offering benefits was a way around the law.
> Of course, once a benefit becomes the norm, it's almost impossible for individual firms to not offer it.
The real reason is that health insurance paid from pre-tax money by the employer makes it cheaper than being post-tax money by the employee. It's the tax system that binds workers to jobs via health care benefits.
Another reason people want wage increases in the form of employer-paid benefits is then they get to lie about the terrible pay they get, because they never ever account for the value of the benefits.
For example, whenever the teachers complain about their salaries, never mentioned are the generous benefits package they get.
Now, sure, supposedly salaries would go up if the company no longer offered health insurance but there are lots of moving parts and people and any such transition would be difficult.
Still, teachers are not paid enough.
Edit: And in turn purposefully growing an existing problem.
>This race to the bottom (disruption) seems counter productive for anything but short term investment.
And you know who most benefits from this type of investment (basically the ones with the big money to invest with little to no real risk to their way of life). So I don't see it ending any time soon...
Definitely not easier in the sense that a sizeable plurality of the country, currently in control of both houses of Congress, the Presidency, the Supreme Court, and the majority of state legislative and executive branches, think this is a terrible idea that they equate with creeping Communism.
The German style system is as probably the system you could have got if people weren't so obsessed with Obamas skin color.
The current "gig economy" trend removes these benefits from employment, and with a government currently opposed to public benefits, the US could be headed towards a problem within a single generation.
This race to the bottom (disruption) seems counter productive for anything but short term investment.