He is the CEO and made a materially false statement, while the market was open and investors who believed him bought at a high of $380 based on a promise of a buyout at $420, only to have it plummet days later. The odds are pretty good that it will dip further when markets open Monday.
Actions have consequences.
Re:Staying Public
by buttcoinslol on Saturday August 25, 2018 @10:13AM
(#17840835)
> The SEC embodies the modern drift of the administrative state at its worst; its many regulations are not laws passed by Congress, which is the only branch empowered to write legislation.
The SEC is empowered by Congress to enact regulation, see the Administrative Procedure Act.
Anyways, as a director of a publicly traded company, Elon Musk is well aware of information disclosure rules.
Your argument is couched in libertarian fantasy, not reality.
This is very nearly "yelling fire in a crowded theater", he's deliberately making false statements (or statements he should have known to be false) from a position of authority with the intention of manipulating the stock market.
The SEC embodies the modern drift of the administrative state at its worst; its many regulations are not laws passed by Congress, which is the only branch empowered to write legislation. One of the most famous and often used SEC rules is Rule 10b-5, which "prohibits fraud in securities transactions as well as insider trading." Fraud is a form of crime, but trading on one's knowledge involves neither force nor fraud and is simply a manifestation of our basic rights to talk and trade, regardless of what others may or may not know.
The proper rule of markets since Roman time is "Caveat Emptor"; don't rely on nor seek to control or punish the morass of conversations at the local inn or at Twitter. Many thoughtful economists and political philosophers suggest that by and large all of the federal securities laws (originated as part of the New Deal in the 1930s) should be abolished. It may be worth considering, when one small online comment becomes fodder for public calls to have the government severely punish a CEO.