Perhaps they should be keeping management on a tighter leash if the only likely outcomes they're capable of are "vanity purchases that destroy value" and buying back stock.
If you've got mountains of free cash, there are a lot more exciting opportunities out there. You can afford to make higher-risk/higher-reward investments. You can buffer yourself from that next surprise recall/product failure/fulfillment problem. You can make sure you have a stake in anything that looks like it could someday be an existential threat.
Re:End Stock Buybacks, Save the Economy?
by mercutio2 on Friday August 24, 2018 @08:02PM
(#17838724)
Removing liquid assets from the balance sheet is the main way boards maintain a tight leash. It’s one step beneath firing an executive.
There’s a reason (many) successful companies don’t just go off and become massive conglomerates attempting to pursue every idea any executive has.
Areas where the board feels it has a competitive advantage, an investment opportunity, and enough management capacity to oversee the new investment are not, in fact, dime a dozen.
Re:End Stock Buybacks, Save the Economy?
by tboyd47 on Thursday August 23, 2018 @09:21PM
(#17832045)
If the owners of all these companies are actually afraid of their own managers allocating funds within the companies they have supposedly invested in, then what's the point of investing in anything at all? In that case, the "economy" is nothing but a bunch of fools wasting investors' money and it is certainly a bubble.
If your employer is afraid of you doing something different from the thing you are supossed to do, what is the point of hiring you in the first place?
The idealized enterprise value of a firm changes not one whit whether capital is returned to investors via a dividend or a stock buy back. There could conceivably be small differences in transaction costs between the two, but in practice, they’re very similar.
Generally, the enterprise value of large amounts of cash for most firms is less-than-par, because investors fear management making vanity purchases that destroy value. So long term investors are much happier if capital is returned, and much happier if the method of return is via stock buy back.