Re:Introduction to Functional Programming in OCaml
by diaz on Thursday August 23, 2018 @10:56AM
(#17827759)
As a contrasting opinion I started reading the Ocaml book about something real world and I felt the syntax finally something fresh, beatiful and clean. But I also suffer from having to use scala everyday at work.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Introduction to Functional Programming in OCaml
by ufo on Thursday August 23, 2018 @11:06AM
(#17827836)
As a big Ocaml fan, the syntax is one of my least favourite aspects of the language.
Two things that I find particularly annoying are constructors (which don't have the same syntax as funciton calls) and the multitude of shift-reduce ambiguities that don't do the thing that you want. For example, in the following code the W gets parsed as part of the inner match:
match foo with
| X -> match bar with
| Y -> 1
| Z -> 2
| W -> 3
A lot of this could be remedied by having more expression terminators. ReasonML uses C-like curly braces but even a simple "end" token to close the match expressoin (similar to what Lua does) would already be enough.
Re:Introduction to Functional Programming in OCaml
by anuragsoni on Thursday August 23, 2018 @11:27AM
(#17828031)
This tripped me up when I was first exploring OCaml. FWIW i've taken to wrapping the nested matches with parenthesis or a begin/end
match foo with
| X -> (match bar with
| Y -> 1
| Z -> 2)
| W -> 3
match foo with
| X -> begin match bar with
| Y -> 1
| Z -> 2
end
| W -> 3
Re:Introduction to Functional Programming in OCaml
by nestorD on Thursday August 23, 2018 @11:46AM
(#17828213)
The indentation sensitive syntax of F# was the solution to me, I would love to see it being integrated into OCaml.