Where are the "savings"? This money was originally earning interest, not costing money.
And of course they need to incorporate the default rate on their loans, which would lower the overall return.
Overall, a very hand wavy plan.
The vast majority of funding for the Bank of North Dakota comes from deposits resulting from tax and fee collections. The bank essentially offers below market rate loans by paying lower deposit rates back to the State, ultimately costing the taxpayer.[1]
[1]https://www.denverpost.com/2015/03/04/colorado-would-be-wise...
Hang on.. is that the rate the bank is lending at, or their yield, including any losses from things like defaults and costs?
> the added benefit of total control over its funds.
Actually, not quite, because one no longer has control of any funds that were lent out.
If a disproportionate number of borrowers all miss a payment during a particular month (even if the don't outright default and catch up next month), the city/bank will have to borrow those funds from the Fed. This can also happen if the city isn't the only depositor and there's a "run" on the bank. That borrowing, short-term though it may be, adds cost, and the rate is (occasionally) variable, unlike, say, many mortgages.
The point is, understanding interest rate spread is simple enough, but the reality (especially with fractional-reserve banking, which is another can of worms) is far more complicated. What seems obvious when explained with the simple model isn't actually so.
Say a current bank gives you 0.1% interest on your deposit and loans that money out at 4.5%. A new bank could pay 2% interest to the depositor and loan the money out at 3.5%. Thus the depositor gets 20x more interest, and the lender pays less.
It is in fact possible to loan out money at a lower interest rate than a private bank while simultaneously collecting a higher rate than the bank pays on deposits because the bank doesn't lend at the same rate it pays out. The larger that spread, the more sense this idea makes. Seems like an elementary mistake for someone leveling the accusation that the scheme isn't well thought out. Surely there's more to your critique than this.