News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Redis will remain BSD licensed by Yiftach on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @01:16PM (#17820223)
Well - I can only say that what MongoDB has is not complete. There are still many holes, and we prefer to avoid them. And of course this doesn't solve the other issue, where developers cannot use AGPL in large enterprises.
Re:Redis will remain BSD licensed by sqrt17 on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @03:12PM (#17821152)
> where developers cannot use AGPL in large enterprises

developers who cannot use AGPL in large enterprises are probably forbidden to use non-open-source software distributed under a shared-source license that allows no commercial use.

A non-charitable reading would be "we want mindshare and adoption from developers in large enterprises who will then buy or software rather than admit that they were unable to understand our terms and assumed our software was liberal open source".

To make things more concrete - while GPL allows unrestricted internal use, the horror scenario would be the contractor who is brought in to work on software including GPLd code and who may have right to receiving the source of everything (as a "derived work"). How is CommonsClause-licensed shared source dealing with large enterprises employing contractors for working with their software? Is the contractor in breach of CommonsClause but the large enterprise isn't?

Re:Redis will remain BSD licensed by yeahforsureman on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @01:30PM (#17820322)
The actual wording of the Commons Clause is very general and ambiguous. I'd be surprised if this didn't continue to cause issues within large enterprises.
Re:Redis will remain BSD licensed by ccleve on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @02:20PM (#17820700)
But that's kind of the point -- those who live in large enterprises who can't use the AGPL must buy a commercial license. The AGPL is toxic in some places, and its use is a deliberate attempt to nudge people toward a commercial license. Did this not work in your case?
Re:Redis will remain BSD licensed by cercatrova on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @02:05PM (#17820570)
Couldn't you sell them the commercially licensed version then, if you had the AGPL + commercial dual license?
Re:Redis will remain BSD licensed by kpcyrd on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @03:15PM (#17821170)
>There are still many holes

As somebody who licenses software as AGPL, could you please list those?