News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Creationism and conspiracism share a common teleological ... by olliej on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @02:22AM (#17816742)
Ok, so right off the bat I have issues with this paper.

* A topic like this, especially with the stated result, seems super likely to be subject to confirmation bias so we need to be careful not to fall prey to that. The paper title seems geared to produce that.

* Study 1 (the college student study) had N=157, and as is the nature of such quizzes seems way too biased to be meaningful given the claims being presented. All were from one university, they received course credit for participating, 135 were psychology students, etc. This is ignoring potential bias in the results (I recall studies discussing the desire of study participants to "help" studies). So I don't believe anything super meaningful should be taken study 1.

* Study 2, French population analysis had a larger sample, but I'd still be reticent to make huge statements. The supplementary material doesn't include the actual quiz questions, but seems to be a 1-4 scale of agreement with a list of conspiracies + horoscope + creationism. The creationist question conflates young earth and creation theories which are obviously correlated but aren't strictly the same (I've known creationists who still realize actual age of earth)

* Study 3 is also super biased, N=513 French and 220 Swiss, 72% of the French participants were students at the host university. Again the Swiss students (but not the French) received course credit for participating. Participants were also informed of the goal of the study ahead of participating which could reasonably be expected to skew data.

Honestly it irks me that a paper like this has got into something like Cell as given the claims being made I would expect/requirer a larger and less biased sample and more information about the actual quiz contents.

Re:Creationism and conspiracism share a common teleological ... by arminiusreturns on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @12:40PM (#17819964)
Thank you for articulating what I was thinking as well. Seems like poor science from my quick reading of it for the same reasons you state.