Re:Titan launches its mobile ‘not a hedge fund’
by theycallhimtom on Tuesday August 21, 2018 @04:01PM
(#17813175)
Both the article and https://www.titanvest.com/performance/ cite performance relative to S&P 500. If you expand out disclosures it says "Figures cited for 2017 and since 2004 represent backtested performance of a hypothetical account using Titan’s investment process, not an actual amount." It's trivial to overfit a backtest to get whatever results you want. For a startup whose objective is to "enable you to become a better investor" they might want to start by explaining why you shouldn't take their performance page seriously.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Titan launches its mobile ‘not a hedge fund’
by AznHisoka on Tuesday August 21, 2018 @05:14PM
(#17813904)
yep and it makes this statement rather suspicious:“Of the ~3500+ hedge funds out there, we track ~5% of them. We believe these are the good guys: long-term oriented and rigorous in their research.”
Its the 5% that performed well in their backtest, but that doesnt mean they will perform the best going forward.
What Titan did in 2016 was chose the top 5% of funds that did well up until that point. Then when they saw it performed bad in 2017, they most likely went back and chose a different 5% that did better. And recalculated all the returns.
The problem is you cant keep doing this once you actually start investing with real money.
Re:Titan launches its mobile ‘not a hedge fund’
by norswap on Tuesday August 21, 2018 @06:18PM
(#17814342)
Do you have any evidence for any of this, or did you just pick the most uncharitable possible scenario and present it as factual?
Re:Titan launches its mobile ‘not a hedge fund’
by sseveran on Tuesday August 21, 2018 @06:37PM
(#17814476)
They should disclose how many backtests were run along with the methodology for evaluation. Backtests should be very rarely run.
Re:Titan launches its mobile ‘not a hedge fund’
by AznHisoka on Tuesday August 21, 2018 @06:33PM
(#17814454)
This is just all theory, of course but this is something most backtesters do, so I wouldnt rule it out.
It helps to be overly skeptical when anyone claims to beat the index. Because it is such a powerful claim.