News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Top geneticist loses 3.5M grant in first test of landmark... by dbcurtis on Tuesday August 21, 2018 @01:22PM (#17811673)
Even that is not helpful to the recipient of the feedback.

How about:

"Here is a list of standards every code check-in is required to meet. Here are the standards that your current P/R fails. Try again. Do you need help with anything specific? When can you have a new P/R ready?."

If applicable: "This delays the schedule, what is your recovery plan?:

And occasionally: "At your pay grade, you are expected to know these standards."

Re:Top geneticist loses 3.5M grant in first test of landmark... by tbrake on Tuesday August 21, 2018 @01:27PM (#17811736)
I find this kind of dispassionate feedback both condescending and nauseating tbqh.

A few f-bombs let me know you care.

Re:Top geneticist loses 3.5M grant in first test of landmark... by dbcurtis on Tuesday August 21, 2018 @01:36PM (#17811841)
Dispassionate? Let me tell you, if you have ever had an ex-commando officer from the Israeli Defense Force as a boss, you will know with every fiber of your being that those words can be delivered with passion.

A passion that leaves no doubt in your mind that "What is your recovery plan?" is not a soft-ball question, and that a soft-ball answer will be promptly discarded. In my case, said boss took part in Operation Entebbe. He ran a very low-BS engineering organization. It was refreshing in a very good way.