You mean, is natural gas extraction and processing more harmful than agriculture and recycling?
It seems plausible that a cloth bag requires a comparable amount of petrochemicals to make than a plastic bag, agriculture is quite fuel intensive and uses a bunch of other nasty chemicals in large amounts, while a few grams of plastic require just a few grams of oil - for me it's hard to tell whether growing sufficient cotton for a single bag (which is quite a bunch of cotton plants) can be done with a few grams of fuel.
Thankfully, this is studied by experts for their entire lives and we don’t have to learn the answers by speculating on Hacker News.
I’ll note that what you’re comparing petroleum based manufacturing to is the most pointlessly intensively harmful and wasteful form of agriculture – growing conventional cotton.
Re:Tiny Plastic Is Everywhere
by marcosdumay on Tuesday August 21, 2018 @10:58AM
(#17810153)
Even without considering the amount of mining required by agriculture, the answer is still non-obvious.
I agree.
>inert foreign molecules
Problem is they're often not inert. The polymers may be, but the bisphenol plasticizers, UV stabilizers, dyes, brominated fire retardants, mold release agents, etc may not be, and they leach out over time.
Re:Tiny Plastic Is Everywhere
by marcosdumay on Tuesday August 21, 2018 @10:57AM
(#17810145)
Do they become reactive inside of living beings? Or just outside due to UV catalyzed hydrolyze?
The molecules I'm speaking of are already reactive. Again it's not just the bulk polymer, there are a bunch of "special ingredients" added to most plastics, plus contaminants introduced during recycling.
I really don't know the answer, but I bet everybody on the anti-plastic crusade doesn't know either. I would really like if somebody cared to do some unbiased studies on this (not the ones full of flaws reinforcing the author desired answer - whatever that it).