I wouldn't ignore the routes that connect Chicago to the rest of the Midwest:
- Route, FY2015 Passengers, ~Distance (miles)
- Chicago – St. Louis, 576,705, 295
- Chicago – Milwaukee, 799,271, 92
- Chicago – Pontiac via Detroit 465,627, 280
These numbers are despite the truly awful experience, in many cases, of waiting long periods for freight traffic to pass. These distances are in the sweet-spot for HSR, which could be quite popular on these routes.
The long pole for speed is lower speed limits in some parts of the route for the benefit of neighbors living along the tracks. Those politics are unlikely to be affected by the technical infrastructure.
At ~90 minutes, the journey from Milwaukee is better than the commute from many parts of Chicagoland.
The other major consumer of rail in the US is freight and they don't generally need high speed rail, and so while I would enjoy having more high speed rail lines as an option I haven't been able to rationalize the use case. Private rail permits use by passenger rail but does not prioritize for it.
Here was a good slide deck that I had been using as reference for a while that has good data on how Amtrak exists at all: https://www.fhwa.dot.gov/Planning/freight_planning/talking_f...