News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Should Rivers Have Rights? A Growing Movement Says It’s Time by xigma on Sunday August 19, 2018 @07:47AM (#17793887)
If a river becomes a legal person, the government can prosecute it for crossing some threshold. The sentence will be forced labor in a dam for 100 years. The duration may sound harsh, but rivers outlive humans by a long margin.
Re:Should Rivers Have Rights? A Growing Movement Says It’s Time by arethuza on Sunday August 19, 2018 @09:25AM (#17794205)
Rivers can be amazingly old - far older, in some cases, than the mountains they cut through or the oceans into which they flow:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_rivers_by_age

The idea that the Congo and the Amazon were once the same river before the Atlantic and the Andes existed is one of my favourites for a bit of geological sensawunda.

Re:Should Rivers Have Rights? A Growing Movement Says It’s Time by mrec on Sunday August 19, 2018 @02:37PM (#17795567)
That's awesome. Particularly the idea that the Amazon, the biggest river (by discharge volume) on the planet, once changed direction.
Re:Should Rivers Have Rights? A Growing Movement Says It’s Time by schiffern on Sunday August 19, 2018 @09:01AM (#17794121)
We managed to avoid silly things like this while making corporations "legal people." I see no reason that legal theorists should be selectively incompetent here.

Don't get caught up on the word "river," which is just a specific example. The general case is "ecosystem."

Re:Should Rivers Have Rights? A Growing Movement Says It’s Time by kazoolist on Sunday August 19, 2018 @09:13AM (#17794157)
The concept behind corporations as "people" is that people don't lose rights just because they are engaging in their right of free association.

The corporate entity only "has rights" because it is a collection of people, and those people have rights.

Ecosystems aren't collections of people.

Re:Should Rivers Have Rights? A Growing Movement Says It’s Time by schiffern on Sunday August 19, 2018 @10:21AM (#17794422)
>Ecosystems aren't collections of people.

Is the implication here that "only people have rights," therefore ecosystems shouldn't? Correct me if mistaken. To clarify, I wasn't arguing that ecosystems have rights because corporations do.

This is indeed the status quo, but it's hardly immutable. Consider that 200 years ago neither women nor slaves were considered legal persons. Restating the status quo isn't an argument in its favor.

Re:Should Rivers Have Rights? A Growing Movement Says It’s Time by rayiner on Sunday August 19, 2018 @10:21AM (#17794420)
Corporations are legal entities composed of people, so it makes sense to treat that the aggregate would have similar rights as the individual. When we say a corporation has the right to free speech, we mean that you cannot restrict the right of people just because they’re acting together through a corporation.

Rivers, of course, are not people nor are they composed of people. Nor are ecosystems. People might be affected by, for example, what happens to a river. All of this legal wrangling over river personhood is an attempt to avoid having to show that effect.

Re:Should Rivers Have Rights? A Growing Movement Says It’s Time by schiffern on Sunday August 19, 2018 @10:50AM (#17794496)
> Nor are ecosystems [composed of people].

Isn't that definition exactly the problem? An ecologist would disagree of course, but how curious that every other species is considered part of the ecosystem, but we are not! We're subject to all the same ecological laws.

The humanity vs. nature separateness is of course entirely invented. But it's built into our very language: consider the other-ing effect of the term "environment" for instance.

> All of this legal wrangling over river personhood is an attempt to avoid having to show that effect.

You have it flipped around. The legal wrangling is almost entirely on the part of polluters seeking to avoid accountability (to great success, I might add). It helps that the 'environmental regulations' are written by the polluting industries themselves.

They use poorly characterized mass flows through the environment (there's that word again) and pollution etiologies (often "poorly characterized" because the company covered up its toxicity research, eg PCBs) like a cryptocurrency tumbler, laundering away their own liability for poisoning their neighbors. It's unconscionable.

Re:Should Rivers Have Rights? A Growing Movement Says It’s Time by maxsilver on Sunday August 19, 2018 @01:59PM (#17795398)
> When we say a corporation has the right to free speech, we mean that you cannot restrict the right of people just because they’re acting together through a corporation.

Why not? We restrict the liability of people, just because they're 'acting together' (a corp). To make that trade off fair, it seems like we should limit their 'rights' together as well. Corporations are sort of fundamentally unfair as they exist in the US, because they get almost all of the rights a real person does, but they have almost none of the responsibilities or liabilities a real person does.

Either [a] corporations should be required to be responsible for their actions (eliminate all limited liability, leadership and shareholders should become personally liable for most actions of the corporation they lead/own), or [b] corporations should loose a lot of their rights as a tradeoff for the reduced responsibilities and liabilities (like the ability for a corporation to have 'free speech').

Re:Should Rivers Have Rights? A Growing Movement Says It’s Time by HillaryBriss on Sunday August 19, 2018 @01:08PM (#17795125)
> cannot restrict the right of people just because they’re acting together

is that a generic legal principle?

Re:Should Rivers Have Rights? A Growing Movement Says It’s Time by pfdietz on Sunday August 19, 2018 @10:25AM (#17794431)
Corporations are a weird kind of person, in that it's perfectly legal to murder them and sell their parts.
Re:Should Rivers Have Rights? A Growing Movement Says It’s Time by Nasrudith on Sunday August 19, 2018 @07:35PM (#17796826)
Well for one corporations have actual people with clearly defined interests and ownership. Who can claim to speak on behalf of the river? At best it gives ownership to the representative to push their interests in an absurd farce like PETA trying to claim copyright on behalf of a monkey who took a picture of himself inadvertently. What is to stop a landowner from claiming what the river really wants is to be a cheap dumping ground for pollutants because it wants to be pretty?
Re:Should Rivers Have Rights? A Growing Movement Says It’s Time by warent on Sunday August 19, 2018 @08:14AM (#17793975)
Isn't there some adage that it's not possible to step in the same river twice?
Re:Should Rivers Have Rights? A Growing Movement Says It’s Time by xigma on Sunday August 19, 2018 @08:47AM (#17794083)
Not according to my grandfather, whose axe had its blade and handle replaced three times each.