News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Researcher at center of epic fraud remains an enigma to t... by DoingIsLearning on Sunday August 19, 2018 @04:06AM (#17793153)
Also one thing that surprised me is that peer reviews are not made blind to the reviewer.

Some things will always be made obvious specially if it's a small field and you know who is doing what.

But if you are reviewer and the 'very famous and respectable' colleague is co-authoring the paper you are reviewig, you are much more likely to dismiss any unclear or incorrect aspects of the paper.

It would seem like a really simple step to just redact any aspects of the paper that would give away names, locations, etc.

Re:Researcher at center of epic fraud remains an enigma to t... by pmyteh on Sunday August 19, 2018 @08:35AM (#17794051)
This is very field-dependent. In mine (political science) it's routine to blind the reviews in both directions. In others, papers are reviewed with the author's name and affiliation on the top.

There is a further issue that if you're in a small-enough (sub-)field you probably know what other people are working on and can effectively unblind the authors anyway.