News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

A comment on A Nerd’s Way to Walk Up the Stairs (2011). Parent comment

Re:A Nerd’s Way to Walk Up the Stairs (2011) by Semiapies on Saturday August 18, 2018 @07:47PM (#17791567)
Yes, but Sherlock Holmes also always magically knows which trivia is important, because he's written that way. He doesn't bother with the count of stairs on every staircase he's ever walked on. And he lives in a world where the trivia he notices always reflects accurately on hidden truths, instead of being simply useless details that reveal nothing of consequence.
[ Parent | on HN ]
Re:A Nerd’s Way to Walk Up the Stairs (2011) by j9461701 on Sunday August 19, 2018 @12:07AM (#17792527)
For example in one story Sherlock deduces that the person sending a ransom note is an educated man attempting to appear stupid, because although the note is grammatically incorrect the newspaper the letters are cut out from was The Times. And only educated men read The Times.

Except....what if that's just coincidence? I mean The Times costs the same amount at a news stand as any paper right? So what if the kidnapper, who is so barely literate he doesn't read any daily paper at all, went to a news stand to buy something to cut the letters from and happened to pick The Times?

[ Parent | on HN ]
Re:A Nerd’s Way to Walk Up the Stairs (2011) by graeme on Sunday August 19, 2018 @10:51AM (#17794500)
George Macdonald Fraser did a funny sendup of this in Flashman and the Tiger, where Holmes creates a completely wrong narrative of Flashman using true facts he observed about him.
[ Parent | on HN ]