edit: It's also not a great list - I'd add a few dozen things to it. I'd like to have a nice way to rate & review projects in Quicklisp, but that's something for the future.
The best thing to do for new users is probably to show up on #lisp and solicit recommended libraries for X, I'm afraid. Or google and read extensively, selecting for newer information where possible.
The Cliki recommended libraries list is a really good idea (I dusted it off and put it on the Cliki front page because of things I read here on HN), but you get flamed for editing it because there's no attribution, Lisp weenies don't like subjective opinions, and I'm guessing certain people get miffed that not everyone loves their library. But please don't let that stop you from using and contributing to the Cliki recommended libraries list in the meantime!
http://www.cliki.net/Current%20recommended%20libraries
Maybe they should be highlighted in the Quicklisp package list?
I'll mention in passing another solution I've found to the dearth of libraries in CL: run CPython via pipes. Then I can call any Python library I want. I used it for GUIs, downloading stuff from the web, and for doing plots with Scipy/matplotlib. It works great, though obviously has some "bandwidth" limitations.