Re:How NASA engineered the Chilean miners' escape pod
by nihilocrat on Sunday October 10, 2010 @08:07PM
(#1778299)
I'm skeptical that merely privatizing NASA or really any other public sector agency would automatically remove bureaucratic fluff, and that bureaucratic fluff is such a gargantuan problem at NASA that removing it would cause a miraculous internal shift for the better. It strikes me as more of a libertarian utopian cure-all than a decision based on NASA's particular problems and objectives.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:How NASA engineered the Chilean miners' escape pod
by ihodes on Sunday October 10, 2010 @08:47PM
(#1778382)
I wouldn't characterize myself as a libertarian, nor do I think that privatizing is a cure-all. You misrepresent me.
What I said and what you portray my comment as saying are very different; contracting with third parties != privatizing NASA.
If SpaceX delivers, they'll be delivering a lot more for a lot less money. I'm sorry that my use of the word competition set off your "libertarian alarm", but I can't see how anything but good is coming out of contracting with SpaceX.
Re:How NASA engineered the Chilean miners' escape pod
by gridspy on Sunday October 10, 2010 @08:39PM
(#1778365)
If not bureaucratic fluff, what is to blame for the great success of organisations such as SpaceX while Nasa has done less with more?
Still, I concede that we must be cautious about potential silver bullets. Good point on the "libertarian utopian cure-all"