Re:Show HN: I made wits.io where writers can earn money with...
by justaguyhere on Friday August 17, 2018 @09:27AM
(#17782634)
Just curious, how does copyright work in this case? To summarize someone's book (especially if we are selling the summaries), don't we have to get permission from the book's authors?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Show HN: I made wits.io where writers can earn money with...
by Tomte on Friday August 17, 2018 @09:44AM
(#17782768)
No. The ideas and the knowledge in the book don't fall under copyright, the concrete expression does.
But the more interesting point is how they use the names of well-known people. They try to pass Elon Musk and Bill Gates off as affiliated with their site.
I'd say there's a pretty good argument that this is illegal and could be shut down hard.
Re:Show HN: I made wits.io where writers can earn money with...
by zaheerbaloch on Friday August 17, 2018 @11:21AM
(#17783485)
Those well-known people are not affiliated with me. These are just book recommendations by those people. And I did put their images on purpose as it makes the site more community looking and trustworthy. Should I mention that I have no affiliation with those founders/ceos?
Re:Show HN: I made wits.io where writers can earn money with...
by sharemywin on Friday August 17, 2018 @09:56AM
(#17782833)
There's nothing wrong with using legal pictures of people. and quotes, but I would just add attribution to the source of the quotes. And statement at the bottom about the company not being affiliated or endorsed by these people.
Re:Show HN: I made wits.io where writers can earn money with...
by Tomte on Friday August 17, 2018 @10:07AM
(#17782907)
I think it gets very close to presenting those people as the authors of summaries/book recommendations on the site.
That‘s what I thought on my first visit, anyway.
Depending how the site is further developed, especially when the summaries are available (they aren‘t, yet, are they?), this concern might disappear. Right now, I wouldn‘t be comfortable running it.
Re:Show HN: I made wits.io where writers can earn money with...
by 505aaron on Friday August 17, 2018 @11:10AM
(#17783390)
I interpreted it the same way too. It looks like Elon Musk and Mark Zuckerberg wrote those summaries. It is blurring the lines between prototype and product.
Re:Show HN: I made wits.io where writers can earn money with...
by zaheerbaloch on Friday August 17, 2018 @01:33PM
(#17784451)
The summaries are currently available after starting the trial. I think it needs more work to show those people didn't contribute those book summaries but rather recommended those books.
Re:Show HN: I made wits.io where writers can earn money with...
by justaguyhere on Friday August 17, 2018 @10:51AM
(#17783231)
Cool. So I can take your book, summarize, sell the summary without having to get your permission first?
The same thing is true for podcasts etc then? Say, I summarize 2 hour podcast into 15 mins?
Re:Show HN: I made wits.io where writers can earn money with...
by nkrisc on Friday August 17, 2018 @01:42PM
(#17784502)
Writing down your thoughts and selling them is perfectly fine and legal in most places. Even if those are thoughts you had after reading a specific book and those thoughts are about the content of that book.
Re:Show HN: I made wits.io where writers can earn money with...
by staticautomatic on Friday August 17, 2018 @11:08AM
(#17783373)
Haven't you ever heard of Cliff Notes?
Re:Show HN: I made wits.io where writers can earn money with...
by pjc50 on Friday August 17, 2018 @10:52AM
(#17783244)
Yes? Provided you're using your own words rather than making large direct excerpts.
Re:Show HN: I made wits.io where writers can earn money with...
by zaheerbaloch on Friday August 17, 2018 @01:19PM
(#17784358)
Yes you can. Until and unless you are using your own words. Same goes for podcasts.
Re:Show HN: I made wits.io where writers can earn money with...
by zaheerbaloch on Friday August 17, 2018 @11:20AM
(#17783475)
Until and unless one is not using the original content from the books as is, there is no copyright issue. I am though worried about using the book covers as they might be an issue. But for now as indie maker I am going with it. If I get a legal notification from someone then will remove the cover images.