News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Facebook is losing the war on hate speech in Myanmar by tomc1985 on Friday August 17, 2018 @02:06AM (#17780610)
Facebook is riding in on its royal horses trying to connect (read: own the primary means of communication) the world like all the classically imperialist westerners before them.

The first thing they teach you in international business and/or marketing is that cultural considerations will destroy you if you do not devote effort to addressing them. If, in building a hyperlocal product (like facebook), you do not take the time to understand your local markets, then they will move in ways that you don't understand and you may not be able to control. Usually at your peril.

edit: as an example.. an international trade professor told us a story about how one of his expat factory managers had an affair with a local girl in a small town in a strongly Buddhist east-asian country. When word of this got out the woman's family raised royal hell for the factory and their operations and the situation was threatening to run the company out of town. Professor said the manager was given a choice: either marry the girl to assuage the locals or leave. (He chose to leave)

Re:Why Facebook is losing the war on hate speech in Myanmar by _vertigo on Friday August 17, 2018 @04:56AM (#17781295)
Wonder how it would have gone over if Facebook had just said from the outset, “We’re not entering Asian markets yet because they’re too culturally different than us.” Bet people would have really liked that.
Re:Why Facebook is losing the war on hate speech in Myanmar by intended on Friday August 17, 2018 @05:15AM (#17781390)
“We will be gradually entering markets as we develop products sensitized to the needs of our hyper local users.”

That Would have sold like iPhones.

Re:Why Facebook is losing the war on hate speech in Myanmar by Nasrudith on Friday August 17, 2018 @08:26AM (#17782245)
That does amusingly sound very stereotypically Japanese corporation and the annoyingly common practice of ignoring viable overseas markets and demands out of a misguided sense of exceptionalism.
Re:Why Facebook is losing the war on hate speech in Myanmar by coldtea on Friday August 17, 2018 @02:40PM (#17784878)
Isn't it their products? Why should they sell them to markets they don't want to sell them to? Because of those markets' misguided sense of entitlement?
Re:Why Facebook is losing the war on hate speech in Myanmar by beaconstudios on Friday August 17, 2018 @07:03AM (#17781838)
I mean, they do some pretty distasteful stuff but saying that providing an international communications platform is imperialist is just beyond silly.
Re:Why Facebook is losing the war on hate speech in Myanmar by tomc1985 on Friday August 17, 2018 @11:20AM (#17783478)
Facebook trying to build an international (business) empire is not "imperialist"? When I used the word I was thinking of Dutch East Indies Co., etc.
Re:Why Facebook is losing the war on hate speech in Myanmar by beaconstudios on Friday August 17, 2018 @11:30AM (#17783538)
you're playing games with words. The various East India companies were imperialist because they dominated the countries they "traded" with. It was more of a militant occupation than an act of mutually beneficial exchange.
Re:Why Facebook is losing the war on hate speech in Myanmar by tomc1985 on Friday August 17, 2018 @12:05PM (#17783760)
But those were different times, when companies could get away with militant operations. To say nothing of strike-breakers, African rubber plantations, or what-have-you. Most companies we know of (esp. American) can't get away with those sorts of things now, at least not in the public eye.

Soft power is the new militant occupation. Facebook is taking cues from Pablo Escobar (minus the violence, we hope).

Re:Why Facebook is losing the war on hate speech in Myanmar by beaconstudios on Friday August 17, 2018 @12:19PM (#17783885)
so in this new world where "soft power" (which I assume means any power imbalance) across borders is imperialism, how can a company be international and not be "imperialist"? Because if they can't then that's the kind of "imperialism" I couldn't care less about.
Re:Why Facebook is losing the war on hate speech in Myanmar by Nasrudith on Friday August 17, 2018 @08:17AM (#17782205)
Sounds like the communist usage of imperialism where anything not part of the nation, them, or their fellow travelers is imperialist even if it is better for the people and noncoerceive because they disrupt the native one. Even if it is say actual honest nongouging medicinal care displacing hedge practitioners who were themselves exploitative. While outsiders looking to make money have a long unfortunate history of doing bad things it is absurd to call them all imperialist or even all bad.

Brings to mind a related observation that the USSR and most 20th century nominal communisms were fascism in communism's skin in practice but that is highly contentious from at least the two extreme sentiment ends on the subject.

Re:Why Facebook is losing the war on hate speech in Myanmar by beaconstudios on Friday August 17, 2018 @08:36AM (#17782305)
> Brings to mind a related observation that the USSR and most 20th century nominal communisms were fascism in communism's skin in practice

They were totalitarian, a property shared with fascism. Also, China and the Soviet Union both claimed to be socialist revolutions on the way to communism, not actual communists, and along the way the dictatorship of the proletariat/vanguard party became "corrupted". Real communism (which is inconsistently defined between different theories anyway) does not and never has existed, and seems like it won't be possible before we reach post-scarcity anyway.

Re:Why Facebook is losing the war on hate speech in Myanmar by nine_k on Friday August 17, 2018 @09:03AM (#17782474)
Both Soviet (and Chinese) parties in power were (and are) nominally "Communist", not "Socialist".

My favorite example of communism implemented in real life is a hermit / monastic retreat, a skete. People devote themselves to voluntarily living an ascetic life, aspiring to the absolute, caring about the common good, and eschewing things like money from daily life.

From the amount of hermits in a society you can estimate how popular this mindset might be, and how realistic is it to involve an entire population into it. Post-scarcity won't solve it, because it's not going to make people automatically care about the common good as a way of self-actualization. This is why the idealist Communist leaders of early Soviets spoke so much about "raising a new man", basically hoping to change the nature of humans.

Re:Why Facebook is losing the war on hate speech in Myanmar by badosu on Friday August 17, 2018 @09:19AM (#17782584)
> My favorite example of communism implemented in real life is a hermit / monastic retreat, a skete

There were allegedly lots of epicurean communities in the antiquities, many of those in Europe, which became monasteries.

Epicurean communes were, for all effects and purposes, communism.

Re:Why Facebook is losing the war on hate speech in Myanmar by beaconstudios on Friday August 17, 2018 @09:19AM (#17782573)
> Both Soviet (and Chinese) parties in power were (and are) nominally "Communist", not "Socialist".

I have to disagree with this, especially given that the CPC claims that China is in the "primary stage" of socialism: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Primary_stage_of_socialism. Communism in its original Marxist form is classless and stateless, which the PRC and the USSR certainly are/were not. Both countries were/are run by communist parties, but said communists recognise/d that a conversion from an agrarian, nominally capitalist society to a communist one would take a long time and require transition through a socialist state, as Marx originally laid out.

> My favorite example of communism implemented in real life is a hermit / monastic retreat, a skete.

The benefit to small communities is that it is easier to police for attitude and morality. Even more so if it's a religious community, though I'm sure Marx is rolling in his grave that you would call a religious community communist given communism's materialist philosophy.

> From the amount of hermits in a society you can estimate how popular this mindset might be, and how realistic is it to involve an entire population into it.

That's putting the cart before the horse somewhat. I know of many people who retreat from society in a hermit-like fashion for reasons other than asceticism or self-actualisation.

> Post-scarcity won't solve it, because it's not going to make people automatically care about the common good as a way of self-actualization.

But it will remove the primary need for an economy: effective distribution of scarce resources. It would also reduce the need for political hierarchy because property rights would become largely unnecessary to enforce.

> This is why the idealist Communist leaders of early Soviets spoke so much about "raising a new man", basically hoping to change the nature of humans.

They spoke about a lot of things that are purely based in ideology and do not gel with how the world works. Lysenkoism and the Four Pests Campaign strike me as good examples.

Re:Why Facebook is losing the war on hate speech in Myanmar by badosu on Friday August 17, 2018 @09:35AM (#17782691)
> The benefit to small communities is that it is easier to police for attitude and morality. Even more so if it's a religious community, though I'm sure Marx is rolling in his grave that you would call a religious community communist given communism's materialist philosophy.

See my comment above on how monasteries came from epicurean communes.

See the title or Marx's PhD thesis: The Difference Between the Democritean and Epicurean Philosophy of Nature

Not so far-fetched.

It's true that communism as envisioned by Karl Marx had a materialistic sense, but so did Epicurus philosophy.

Communism is Karl Marx's scaling attempt at Epicurean communes. Not a very good idea IMO.

Re:Why Facebook is losing the war on hate speech in Myanmar by beaconstudios on Friday August 17, 2018 @09:42AM (#17782749)
that's an interesting piece of philosophical history I didn't know about, thanks for sharing that. I always thought there were strong parallels between ancient Greek philosophy and the primary strands of modern politics.

> Communism is Karl Marx's scaling attempt at Epicurean communes. Not a very good idea IMO.

I tend to think that the idea wasn't bad, but people trying to force it to occur faster than the natural societal evolution end up killing a lot of people. The debates we're seeing now about how to deal with automation of large swathes of the job market are similar to Marx's theory that socialism would automate production to the point of creating a post-scarcity society. Of course, that doesn't account for the environment, but then global warming wasn't on the menu in the mid 1800s.

The ironic thing is that it's capitalism that is doing the automating.

Re:Why Facebook is losing the war on hate speech in Myanmar by badosu on Friday August 17, 2018 @09:47AM (#17782783)
> I tend to think that the idea wasn't bad, but people trying to force it to occur faster than the natural societal evolution end up killing a lot of people.

Exactly, although I don't believe we can infer to which point the society would naturally evolve. If possible, the probable transition would be from scattered communes to a commune federation. The drawback being that it would be difficult to have political cohesion (not that this is bad, but easily corruptible by neighboring states).

> The ironic thing is that it's capitalism that is doing the automating.

Interesting insight.

Re:Why Facebook is losing the war on hate speech in Myanmar by 0x445442 on Friday August 17, 2018 @09:20AM (#17782587)
Post scarcity wouldn't matter anyway. You'd still have the problems of who watches the watchers and the idea that some of us are more equal than others... There is no Star Trek utopia.
Re:Why Facebook is losing the war on hate speech in Myanmar by beaconstudios on Friday August 17, 2018 @09:28AM (#17782643)
> You'd still have the problems of who watches the watchers

Could you expand on what you mean by this? If you remove the concept of material wealth (as a distinction between individuals), the cause for conflict is greatly reduced.

> the idea that some of us are more equal than others

I don't see how this would continue to cause conflicts once people's material needs and wants are all met. People tend to hate on exceptional people because they have access to more things.

> There is no Star Trek utopia.

Certainly not now, but it's a good goal to aim for.

Re:Why Facebook is losing the war on hate speech in Myanmar by coldtea on Friday August 17, 2018 @02:42PM (#17784893)
Actually it's very apt, whether the intention was imperialist or not the result inevitably is: a single company from a single culture/country controls an important communications channel globally.

Besides, the intention is very much imperialist - to conquer the global markets. So much so that "world domination" is a standard part of business parlance.

Re:Why Facebook is losing the war on hate speech in Myanmar by beaconstudios on Friday August 17, 2018 @06:24PM (#17785866)
that's a pretty loose definition of imperialism. Conquering markets is not coercive, it's not an act of one group dominating another (beyond the realm of permissible competition that is the whole point of markets existing). Every company wants to reach the top of its market so at what point does the average company become "imperialist"? When it starts trading overseas?

It weakens the concept of imperialism to the point of almost meaninglessness - it essentially becomes the same concept as globalisation. The nasty element of old-school mercantilist imperialism was its subjugation of the native people of other countries. If you remove the harmful element from the equation but continue to use the word for effect, you're playing games with words to cast something as bad without due cause.

If you want to suggest that, say, oil companies moving operations into African nations (I forget exactly which ones, but read about it a few years ago), hiring military contractors, and reaping another country's natural resources is imperialism, then yes I totally agree. Putting something on the internet and letting people from other nations use it? Not even slightly.

Re:Why Facebook is losing the war on hate speech in Myanmar by coldtea on Saturday August 18, 2018 @06:54AM (#17787921)
>that's a pretty loose definition of imperialism. Conquering markets is not coercive, it's not an act of one group dominating another (beyond the realm of permissible competition that is the whole point of markets existing).

Well, conquering markets also imposes one group's values (e.g. FB censorship based on what Americans deem offensive) and national interests (e.g. surveillance) on others.

>It weakens the concept of imperialism to the point of almost meaninglessness - it essentially becomes the same concept as globalisation.

Well, globalization is a form of imperialism. It's not equal access to the global markets and influence for all countries: it's a few countries dominating.

Re:Why Facebook is losing the war on hate speech in Myanmar by beaconstudios on Saturday August 18, 2018 @01:41PM (#17789587)
> Well, conquering markets also imposes one group's values (e.g. FB censorship based on what Americans deem offensive) and national interests (e.g. surveillance) on others.

That's a great pro-free-speech and privacy argument. Certainly interacting within the framework of a company with different values will mean you have to abide by those values. But the thing is - you aren't forced to. The various peoples of colonies usually didn't have a choice to go back to living how they did before their foreign occupiers landed.

> Well, globalization is a form of imperialism. It's not equal access to the global markets and influence for all countries: it's a few countries dominating.

As far as I'm aware, the living standard of all nations is going up. Nigerians have access to a safer banking system because they can use modern phones. China is dominating the world's manufacturing. Sure, the US and Europe have an outsized impact on the market - do you think that is more the case now than in the 1800s? I'd much rather people in developing nations have access to the international markets, because trade is mutually beneficial. Big companies make money, their customers also gain something. That's not imperialist in any sense, that's just free exchange of goods and services. Or perhaps we should all stick to trading within our own borders? Because that sounds like protectionist nationalism, which certainly isn't going to give people living in poorer nations access to goods and services they may benefit from.

Re:Why Facebook is losing the war on hate speech in Myanmar by raverbashing on Friday August 17, 2018 @09:00AM (#17782450)
> The first thing they teach you in international business and/or marketing is that cultural considerations will destroy you

True, but I'm not sure it's the 1st thing they teach, given the multiple failures in this area

Or, put it more simply (and I love this phrase): Culture eats strategy for breakfast