If not, what makes Facebook different? Do we want Facebook to be the arbiter of what we are allowed to say to each other, or do we want them to be a neutral carrier for communications?
The content in question isn't private messages, it's public (and shareable!) posts. We would absolutely expect, for example, the New York Times to disallow classified ads organizing lynch mobs.
If it were just a general hateful statement like "I hate the Jews" that someone wanted post in a classified ad, I don't know that the NY Times would necessarily stop that, nor that they should if we're going to have free speech.
Insofar as people are doing things on Facebook's platform that they themselves disagree with, it's absolutely their responsibility to stop it. How ridiculous does this sound: "Alice says she's going to buy this knife from me to stab Bob. I don't like stabbings, but I'm going to sell it to her anyway, because it's the government's job to stop stabbings, not mine."
> nor that they should if we're going to have free speech.
It's incumbent on states to recognize freedom of speech, not private entities. The NYT deciding whether or not to publish something has zero impact on that.
Yes, it is ultimately the state's responsibility to uphold the freedom of speech. That doesn't mean that any private actor is prohibited from providing a platform that upholds freedom of speech, only that they are not obligated to do so. You can do something even if you're not legally obligated to, you know.
> Insofar as people are doing things on Facebook's platform that they themselves disagree with, it's absolutely their responsibility to stop it.
So you mean like, if there were a candidate for US President that Facebook didn't like, then Facebook should refuse to run ads for that candidate. And if people used Facebook to talk about or promote that candidate, then Facebook should delete their posts right? I mean, if Facebook is responsible for stopping everything they disagree with, that should follow then.
The knife isn't killing Bob, Alice is! The point being, both the knife-seller in the analogy and Facebook in real life bear a nonzero amount of responsibility for known consequences of their actions.
We can actually make this analogy a little clearer: would you sell a knife to someone knowing they planned to stab you, because it's the government's job to prevent stabbings?
And obviously Facebook isn't prohibited from allowing these posts, or we wouldn't be having this discussion. The claim is that they have a moral obligation to take down this content, any legal obligations notwithstanding.
Regarding your Presidential campaigns analogy, it's not that Facebook (or any entity) should censor speech they disagree with. They should prevent behavior they disagree with, in a moral sense; those can be the same or different. It's not incoherent to believe that political discourse is valuable even when you disagree with the ideas, and that hate speech falls outside the bounds of acceptable discourse.
> We can actually make this analogy a little clearer: would you sell a knife to someone knowing they planned to stab you
Absolutely. This would be an excellent opportunity to sell them a fake knife. Also, now I'm aware that someone is trying to kill me, so I can do something about it. Kind of a best case scenario for me.
> They should prevent behavior they disagree with
Voting for a particular candidate would be an example of behavior that Facebook might try to prevent. I find it highly disturbing that anyone would want to assign Facebook the power of controlling our behavior. That is a power we grant to governments, and then reluctantly, and only with appropriate checks and balances. Not something we should hand out to private companies with no accountability.
Secondly, telephones, unlike Facebook, are designed primarily for person-to-person, not group communication. Communication dynamics are very different between the two models.
Facebook is a private entity that can do as they please. It most certainly is not a neutral carrier for communications, and to treat it as such is foolish.
If the cost and effectiveness was comparable, and the government showed no interest in stopping it, yes.
> Do we want Facebook to be the arbiter of what we are allowed to say to each other, or do we want them to be a neutral carrier for communications
If the alternative is genocide, I don't want Facebook to be a neutral carrier for communications.
At the best they probably machine learning translated it and have no idea what the text really meant.
1. It's not a trivial problem to be able to identify what is hate speech in a regional dialect automatically
2. It sets a problematic precedent if Facebook throws 100s of - hard to find, hard to pay and hard to support - native language local reviewers at every place where Facebook could be abused.
I'm no Facebook apologist, however I recognize how hard of a technical problem, and how it's equally a personnel management, prioritization and scaling problem.
Facebook risks chasing every group that makes a loud enough noise, and then being criticized for it irrespective of what they do. No win situation.
In what way is that a problematic precedent? Their negligence contributed to ethnic cleansing and genocide. If a multi-billion dollar company is too cheap to hire local staff to watch its platform, it shouldn't operate a localized version for that place. They need to act responsibly. Think if it like product safety testing.
If Facebook didn't have a version localized to Burmese, it would never have gotten widespread enough in Myanmar to be a significant part of the problem.
> It's not a trivial problem to be able to
> identify what is hate speech in a regional
> dialect automatically
This sentiment, which I read repeatedly, really irritates me. Most of us program here. It's not that hard a problem! When social media execs claim it is, what they really mean is "it's a hard problem to solve for us, because we are unwilling to risk losing any percentage of account sign-ups ever, under any circumstances."The irony is that they are so timid about their precious sign-ups that they act against their own interest. For example, YouTube won't risk a short term dip in user retention metrics to scrub garbage from their comments... even though doing so would likely greatly increase sign-ups in the long term.
i.e:
"get rid of all black people"
"get rid of all black people unemployment problems"
"get rid of all black people unemployment problems sending them back to Africa"
this can be expanded almost infinitely in every direction, and we're not even beginning with the false positive problems.
"I hate black cars"
so no, it's not just a claim that it's an hard problem.
> natural language processing is like one
> of the hardest problems that's left to crack
You don't need to "crack it" or come anywhere remotely near to a perfect solution. False positives are okay, providing you accept that some percent of your users won't tolerate the errors, and will leave your platform.And we're talking about social networks. So there's a wealth of additional information (ie: who you follow. previous behavior. who has reported you. account age) beyond plain text to augment this. And there's the setting of policy (eg: how come I can post within an hour of signing up on most social networks?).
The point is, what we have now on most social networks is not geared toward long-term customer satisfaction or the public good. It's geared toward medium-term account retention at any cost - regardless of whether the accounts are bots, sock puppets, or trolls.
What solution do you think would work?
It's not hard to think of ways to aggressively moderate a social network. It's just that some users (certainly the most toxic ones) will leave.
First, because the use of the word can be in a positive or negative sentence, and thus can either agree or disagree with your "censorship rule". You need a deeper NLP analysis to disambiguate.
Second, because - if online fora with this kind of ban has taught us anything - it's pretty easy to work around it by using punctuation, replacement characters, or other style variations to write the word in a way that it won't be caught by the regex.
Third, this method ends up banning legit words. There was a forum where I couldn't write "booby trap". I don't need to explain.
WRT reputation, networks that allow "unlimited registrations" are easy targets for https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sybil_attack - One can use account age to mitigate of course, but given the amount of fake accounts that exist on the market (look at fiverr marketing offers) with long life and activity, I wouldn't expect age to be that big of a helper.
> Word banning is known to be a poor method.
It's a "poor method" if you're seeking perfection. We don't need perfection. > You need a deeper NLP analysis to disambiguate.
Ixnay. Only if you have zero tolerance for false positives.If users really can't understand why their website won't let them type "n-----" in a public message, even in good faith... well, I just don't know what to add.
> it's pretty easy to work around it by using punctuation,
> replacement characters, or other style variations to write the
> word in a way that it won't be caught by the regex.
Still an improvement. Easier to ID problem users. Not the only line of defense. > "booby trap". I don't need to explain.
Sure. I can live with that. You realize the alternative is the Youtube comments section. I don't feel comfortable posting there ever. I can live with finding synonyms for "booby trap" etc. I might actually enjoy commenting on my favorite YouTube videos, an activity that feels utterly meaningless with the current milieu of lunatics. > networks that allow "unlimited registrations" are easy targets
> for https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sybil_attack - One can use
I imagine this could be handled much better than the social networks do now. Time-stamped accounts, data mining, user reporting. There has been ZERO incentive to rid ANY accounts till the past year, because bots, sock puppets and trolls still "help" a company's user growth, on paper.The problem isn't that solutions are hard to think of, it's that the incentives are horrible for these companies. They don't really care about anything but growth.
Ya, that is neglectful, but accusing them of aiding in inciting racial hatred and genocide is disingenuous.
I think it's because they were given ample, clear warnings that their platform was being used to incite ethnic hatred and genocide, but chose to do nothing for years. I don't think they would be getting so nearly so much blame if they hadn't been so utterly negligent about the problem. They didn't even bother to translate their objectionable content reporting tools into Burmese until a few months ago, long after the persecution started.
When you are repeatedly notified by human rights groups and the local government that your essentially unmoderated social network is being used to organize lynch mobs, you should either shut it down or hire enough moderators to control the problem.