I run an online community and what this article describes has happened to me a few times already, even with a karma/reputation system in place. I know I must fix the problem, but I don't know how right now.
Does anyone have specific suggestions on how to broadly lessen this kind of problem?
Other people will want other things from what I want. And you will need to find some healthy means to balance meeting their needs with the needs of the forum. I have seen forums go completely to hell because it got all twisted out of shape to meet the need of one or more top members in a really unhealthy manner. So while trying to find out what your best people want, don't let it become their personal pond to piss in either. You want to foster an environment that is highly likely to consistently provide things that more than one top member is looking for without specifically making it about them as an individual. Don't prostitute the forum to them as an individual but shape the forum to be highly likely to provide X, Y or Z so that most of your current top members are likely to stay but fresh blood will also be attracted.
HTH.
This kind of kept happening, but every time it got worse and worse. It wasn't until reading this article that I realized that they weren't "taking over" or "stepping up," but they were simply the next highest level.
I've seen it happen and tried to warn people who manage those communities of it.. usually with little success. Great article though, explains the concept extremely well.