Re:Self-learning is overrated (in programming)
by dasil003 on Sunday October 10, 2010 @03:19PM
(#1777724)
Without knowing what your self-learning experience is, this is meaningless. You don't mention it once. Have you been hacking personal Haskell projects for 10 years in your sparetime (let's say 25% of your professional experience?), or just read a book or two, or nothing at all?
Personally I think it's pretty easy to make the opposite argument. If you work on open source software in your spare time you have a chance to work with a wider pool of more talented engineers in a more collaborative environment and wider ecosystem of software than exists in any single company. Many programming jobs by comparison involve either menial CRUD-style work, or working for years on end on some specific component that does not convey much general-purpose knowledge.
Now, if you aren't the kind of guy that is motivated to work on your own then certainly a business environment will be invaluable, however I reject the idea that corporate programming somehow inherently teaches you more than you can learn on your own.
Personally I think it's pretty easy to make the opposite argument. If you work on open source software in your spare time you have a chance to work with a wider pool of more talented engineers in a more collaborative environment and wider ecosystem of software than exists in any single company. Many programming jobs by comparison involve either menial CRUD-style work, or working for years on end on some specific component that does not convey much general-purpose knowledge.
Now, if you aren't the kind of guy that is motivated to work on your own then certainly a business environment will be invaluable, however I reject the idea that corporate programming somehow inherently teaches you more than you can learn on your own.