Re:Why "Star Wars" Created a Fanatical Subculture and "Ameri...
by philwelch on Sunday October 10, 2010 @01:54PM
(#1777523)
Voyager and Enterprise got (and deserve) a lot of criticism, but DS9, at least while it was airing, was very widely respected as possibly the best Star Trek series ever produced. And that's because the writers realized that, at the time, the premise of space travel to strange alien worlds was not fantastic enough to hold viewer attention. Where TNG and especially TOS featured some new, strange thing each week (be it a fantastically powerful noncorporeal entity or a planet killer or a Dyson sphere), DS9 mostly took its world as a given and built a compelling, continuous drama out of those elements. It's quite similar to how the new Battlestar Galactica was constructed, and BSG developed a small, passionate fanbase during its run. (Not coincidentally, BSG had a number of DS9 writers on its staff.)
I also disagree that it's too late for a reboot. The reboot was the single most successful Star Trek movie ever produced.
I also disagree that it's too late for a reboot. The reboot was the single most successful Star Trek movie ever produced.