Haha, that is exactly what I was thinking - we've already picked combustion engines, the infrastructure for which is now solidly entrenched. This status-quo is very unlikely to be broken without additional incentives, so subsidies seem to me a good way of getting out of a local optimum.
This is one of the reasons you have for making choices and having mandated standards for interoperability. Building infrastructure is expensive and if you do it right it lasts for a long time.
From an infrastructure standpoint electric cars have some serious advantages over hydrogen, since we already have extensive experience building electrical infrastructure. And it should be possible to improve batteries without replacing entire vehicles. And electric vehicles create an opening for small entreprneurial companies to try out new devices in ways that hydrogen with it's high barriers to entry and need for a massive infrastructure upgrade do not.
electric and hydrogen are only 2 options. We should wait for one that can actually beat the gasoline engine.
all we need do is make sure that the total costs of using gasoline are paid by those choosing to use it. That means taxing emissions too.
if another technology can beat gasoline when all costs of both are considered, it should replace gasoline. And if nothing succeeds at doing that, then no big change makes ense
I'd say that motors that are far more mechanically efficient than gas engines, a fuel distribution infrastructure that's already in place (electricity mains) and in-car storage of fuel that has made enormous leaps in the past few years and shows no signs of slowing down pretty much qualifies as beating the gasoline engine.
With scale, costs will be lower; there are fewer moving parts, all elements of power distribution and use can be independently upgraded to improve the efficiency and impact of the car. Gasoline cars cannot do this.
Gasoline looks quite beat to me.
we didn't have Steve Jobs going to DC to explain how his product is better than other phones and therefore needs a subsidy.
new products should prove themselves as they always have. it should not be whichever product that has presented for it the most widely believed theory that wins
if its so great, it should be able to garner investment dollars all on its own.
Dcespite that, the cars being produced by Tesla are price competitive, and are on track to do just that, despite the subsidies.
If we had to pay the actual costs directly, our behavior would change. I am all for ending this subsidy. We'd have higher prices at peak times and flatter demand and less need to gobble of land for highways.
But what technology people use to drive on any road is another question entirely.
But it seems government can never undo any policy. It must always layer some other policy on top of it. Until the whole structure collapses under its own weight and a younger smarter country invades.
Tell them they'll be paying $20 a week for their roads and that their taxes will be going down $30 a week, they will scream about how terrible it is.
The problem with taking a hands-off approach to competing technologies is that it's not a level playing field with the entrenched technologies at all. There are subsidies and externalized costs all the way along the hydrocarbon supply chain.
If there were some other promising type of alternative vehicle coming out, I'm sure there would be tax credits for them as well, but right now there aren't really any other practical alternatives to EVs.
And all policies start. After a couple of years, a tax credit is always only a couple of years old. I don't see how long a policy has been in please is relevant in deciding whether it should be.
By the way, a lot of the additional electricity required for electric vehicles will have to be generated by burning oil.
Of course it might make more sense to tax the pollution than for government to try to pick the next technology. Didn't George Bush tell us it was going to be hydrogen cars? Now its supposed to be electric, but who knows what will actually happen in reality?
When you pick one technology and give it all of the advantages, it makes it all that much harder for competing technologies to succeed. A level playing field is best.
We have an entire industry of people trying to figure out what technologies will win. They compete with each other and have all kinds of different backgrounds and differing opinions. And they learn as they go, something Washington seems incapable of doing.