Emphasis on the word "I." Some people don't "get" books. Some people don't "get" e-mail newsletters. Some people don't "get" movies. Some people find in-person, live presentations useless to learn from.
Different strokes for different folks.
Video has an interesting psychological effect for many users. Most of us have grown up watching a fair bit of TV and, often, watching a lot more TV than reading books. There can be some comfort and ease with video versus reading, at least to build motivation and to "get going" with a topic. But, of course, not for everyone.
For most people who appreciate screencasts (I surveyed my ~ 1500 users), it's mostly a casual way to get familiar with a given subject before diving into it through books or articles or blogs, or a way to keep up to date (eg: railscasts).
It seems to be really appreciated while commuting, for some reason.
But there are also people that cannot stand screencasts at all, too.
At the end, I believe it's really more a supplemental format, yes.
Edit: All that said, anyone who takes the time to teach others, regardless of the format, deserves a lot of credit.