Biopharma is a perfect example. It represents over 20% of venture funding. Most entrepreneurs are 50+ years old. Big companies get orders of magnitude lower return on r&d investment than VC backed companies. And the returns have actually been better than tech startups in the last few years
Even if they overcome it they will still have lower returns than a startup who steals 100% of their market share from incumbents.
Strong disagree. Living in San Francisco I often hear the phrase “I work at a small startup, we have just 100 employees”
That is significantly different than what you describe which is more of a 5 to 20 people stage. By the time you have 100+ employees and are hitting proper growth curves, your management can no longer be shit, there has to be mentoring, and there’s little room for shit employees.
Is that even a startup anymore? To me, any company of that size is just a normal company, not a startup.
Plenty of startups here in the bay with well over 100 employees.
This is rare. Most companies do not have processes for change and innovation, and the only way anything gets done is if the CEO pushes hard for it. Those things are far and few between.
" Well, of course your management is going to be shit."
It's only 'shit' if you assume managements job is to provide clear and detailed plans on how it's going to work out. If you grasp that startups have inherent ambiguity, and that all systems have to be highly adaptive and you'll be 'micro-pivoting' every week, well, then management may not seem so bad, depending on.
Good, thoughtful, professional managers might often fail miserably at a startup. It takes a little bit of experience actually to recognize what makes good leadership in a dynamic situation, because often it's counterintuitive.
Let me explain; it's reported very very often on YC that 90% of startups fail, and while a lot of these points in the article are disguised as separate ideas, they're all part of the same problem being that people want to make something from nothing, hence why it is called a startup. Traditional businesses begin by pivoting off an exiting business or product, whereby if you're a chemist working for DuPont and develop a new chemical, they might make a subsidiary to produce that. That process is way easier, the money and infrastructure is already there, and everyone is already neatly on board.
Contrast this with a startup. You're probably young, lacking financial and networking support, education, and many other things. You want to make a product the world has likely never seen before, completely from scratch. Well, of course your management is going to be shit. Of course you're going to find shit employees. Of course it's unlikely to succeed. This article was completely unnecessary because everyone should know by now what a startup entails, and that it is fundamentally unstable, but that doesn't mean it's not important as a venture and concept.