Sorry to be rude but this is a very personal and emotional topic to me and you’ve really pissed me off by saying “They are superior to gasoline engines in every way.” You apparently aren’t living in a city where the poor-sighted decision was made to promote Diesel engines over gasoline for marginally better CO2 metrics, and now get to breathe air that exceeds annual EU pollution limits in mere days.
Diesel is terrible in urban settings. It’s dirty as hell. I have no idea where you live but Diesel engines are entirely on their own choking the streets of London with their particulates and NoX exhaust. Gasoline engines are much cleaner by comparison.
I’ve gotten bronchitis several times in the past few years. I’ve finally tracked it down to the nox fumes, primarily from buses and heavy trucks where it’s a very noticeable sharp smell. I’ve gotten a bit better by avoiding high streets whenever possible, and I’m also proactively going up to drivers in idling diesel cars and asking them to cut the engine. It’s been estimated that 10k people are dying a year in London alone from effects of the exhaust!!
Oh, I'd really love to hear how you did that.
The tricky part is that there’s usually a delay of a few hours between exposure and cough attack. Intentionally avoiding high streets has helped for me. I still get coughing fits but not as many full on cases.
So to limit particulates, add a throttle limiter that limits throttle changes to a certain speed where the temperature of combustion increases proportionate to the fuel being injected.
You can also reduce soot output by filtering the fuel. You can refine diesel until you're blue in the face, but the fact of the matter is you get to a point where the cost of refining it isn't worth the benefit coming out of the tail pipe.
Not to mention the soot falls back to Earth and doesn't stay in the atmosphere as long as you think it does. So much of that black cloud is getting washed into your sewers when it rains.
You've found a bug in your code and you want to throw it all out and start over?
Though you appear to have some vested interest in the proliferation of Diesel engines.
I owned a 1990 CTD Dodge W350 truck and that thing would do a brakestand from a 3rd gear clutch drop AT IDLE... with 300k miles on the clock. Find me a V8 gasser that can do that and pull a trailer through the Kangamangus at 20+mpg.
2) references please (for you arguments)
The more common solution it diesel particulate filters in-line of the exhaust pipe that cause the soot to completely burn off. This is a trade-off because the DPF requires maintenance. Some systems even go so far as to implement aggressive exhaust gas recycling, pumping already burned exhaust back into the intake to be burned again.
And for references... 1. Why do diesels produce black smoke..... https://commercial.lubrizoladditives360.com/black-smoke-caus...
2. What is diesel exhaust..... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diesel_exhaust
3. Diesel misconceptions..... https://phys.org/news/2011-06-myths-diesel.html
What about pollution? There is sufficient evidence that the fine particles cause cancer
[0]https://www.cancer.org/cancer/cancer-causes/diesel-exhaust-a...
Diesels are only good for limited purposes, like buses and trucks, that need the higher efficiency.
sources and additional reading: https://pubs.acs.org/doi/pdf/10.1021/es034928d
https://phys.org/news/2017-05-carcinogenic-soot-particles-pe...
https://www.energy.gov/sites/prod/files/2014/03/f9/2002_deer...
Second paper only considers fine-size (<20 nm) particulates (and not larger sizes like 100nm+) of direct injection cars, and is a bit misleading by comparing six cars to a single carefully-selected diesel car with particulate filter. Further, in reality here in a London, people are cutting open their Diesel particulate filters to avoid cost of replacing clogged filters and still passing MOT exhaust tests, which apparently don’t/can’t check for filter tampering.
Third paper is way back in 2002 and considers only cars, not heavy trucks and buses, which are way worse in urban settings.
We're really having this conversation about combustion. For city driving of all types, it's time is very nearly up.
Gasoline engines have lesser thermal efficiency and lesser torque potential than diesel engines. If you're going to get rid of one or the other, get rid of gasoline vehicles.
Diesel engines have a longer stroke, cooler combustion, more flexibility with air/fuel ratios, extreme wear tolerance, lower rotational speeds, and cost the same with similar complexity to gasoline engines. They are also more economical in practice because their extra low-end torque gives them (arguably) a drivability advantage which lends itself to increased MPG.
They are superior to gasoline engines in every way. And because they can run with air/fuel ratios anywhere from 10:1 all the way to 60:1 they can easily run a mutitude of different fuel's with only minor software adjustments.
So please, stop shitting on diesel. It's ignorant to the fact that you probably drive a gasoline powered car that does more damage to the environment per gallon of fuel burned than a diesel bus.