Some key differences between what we're doing and Digg, Newsvine:
-news networks --> everything starts with topical networks that members create and join and have full control of
-members can feed in news from any number of sources into their news networks, not just rely on user submissions. IN fact, upon entering some topics (like keywords), we go crawl the web and suggest sources the might want to include.
-today, all news networks on socialmedian are public -- anyone can create and join them. soon, we'll also layer on private networks
-Everything on socialmedian revolves around the member's personalized feed on their homepage. Our algo offers up a personalized view on the news unique to each user based on their interests. We'll also be layering on some unique types of filters (e.g. know what certain types of people are reading)
more on the way :) it's early. only been at it 2 months
Join 3-4 news networks, create 1, and then check out your homepage. Then give us some feedback as to how to make this work for you.
I think you guys are using Rails, but the site is just so dogslow, why? Perhaps consider adding more mongrel instances, are your servers hitting its load with only 2000 users? The slowness of the site sorted of turned me off when I first tried the site. Remember social news is a tough market to fight in, so the first impression counts.
I also suggest you post your design competition on 99designs.com, I'm not sure how many people knows about your design competition. A $1000 prize would definitely draw a lot of entries.
Any finally, is Jason Goldberg - the Jason Goldberg from Jobster? Just curious.