News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hal Lewis: My Resignation From The American Physical Society by jacquesm on Saturday October 09, 2010 @01:02PM (#1775314)
Cue the global warming conspiracy theorists to spin this far and wide.

What makes it interesting is that to me there really can't be a global warming scam, it either is real, or it is not, we may be able to do something about it, or it may turn out we're along for the ride.

But which ever of those is the case it is not going to hurt us one bit to know.

Writing it all off as a scam is going way too fast, some people have been messing with the data, that much has been established but we are nowhere near the point where the whole thing should be written off.

edit: would the downmodders be so kind as to explain which part of the above was the reason for the moderation?

Re:Hal Lewis: My Resignation From The American Physical Society by mquander on Saturday October 09, 2010 @01:43PM (#1775407)
I downmodded this because it's content-free ("Either AGW is real, or it's not. Maybe we should find out.") and it's sprinkled with emotionally-laden words like "scam" and "conspiracy theorists." I don't think it's good to approach a flamewar-prone topic like that.
Re:Hal Lewis: My Resignation From The American Physical Society by jacquesm on Saturday October 09, 2010 @01:48PM (#1775416)
Thanks for that input.

It is real or it is not is simply indicating that I think that as far as the science is concerned this is still an open question, even though you can find plenty of stuff out there which states with great levels of certitude that it is the one or the other, I simply disagree with that.

As for the conspiracy theorists, yes, I really do believe they will be all over this, any high profile person that would use words like "It is of course, the global warming scam" (which came directly from the article) is going to find their words quoted forever by those that would rather deny the possibility of this somehow being effected by humanity.

I'm on the fence I'd like to know but I don't, anybody that is yelling 'scam' or 'for sure' is most likely pushing an agenda.

So I'm all for science to be done here preferably in as independent a style as possible with a strong accent on transparency.

Re:Hal Lewis: My Resignation From The American Physical Society by lzw on Saturday October 09, 2010 @04:12PM (#1775741)
Why do you say you're on the fence when you characterize those who are skeptical of the AGW theory as "conspiracy theorists"?

As an aside, I find this characterization generally amusing because it seems to come from an assumption that conspiracies are so rare as to not be worth considering. The climategate scandal is a pretty clear conspiracy. In fact, the review policy of APS that he's objecting to is a conspiracy. I think it would be hard to argue that conspiracies are rare. Every time more than one person cooperates to hide, obscure or perpetuate a fraud, it is a conspiracy. APS's policies that affect selection of papers based on a pre-scientific conclusion are in effect a fraudulent distortion of the state of the art in physics.

This isn't like finding a unicorn.

Re:Hal Lewis: My Resignation From The American Physical Society by jacquesm on Saturday October 09, 2010 @04:38PM (#1775807)
Being skeptical is one thing, categorically dismissing each and every finding of fact as cooked up to manufacture a story that has not rational basis is quite another.

Everybody is entitled to their opinions, but not everybody gets to have their own facts.

Global warming is not a theory, it is a fact, enough evidence that is beyond reproach of any kind is left that we can safely conclude that this is apparently really so.

What remains is whether - and if so to what extent - we are contributory to this and regardless of whether we are if this is something that we can do something about it and if we should (assuming that we can).

Conspiracy theorists reject the whole thing out of hand and make it seem as though all of it, evidence included was made up. That puts them right out there with the people that don't believe men ever walked on the moon.

There are conspiracy theorists on both sides of this debate, and somewhere in the middle you will find people working hard - and not all of them because they are on the payroll of an institution with an agenda- to try to find out what is really going on.

Re:Hal Lewis: My Resignation From The American Physical Society by tbrownaw on Saturday October 09, 2010 @06:11PM (#1776023)
> Global warming is not a theory, it is a fact, enough evidence that is beyond reproach of any kind is left that we can safely conclude that this is apparently really so.

Relativity is a theory, even though it has been experimentally verified. Newtonian mechanics and the luminiferous aether are also theories.

Gravity, global warming (on any given timescale), the freezing point of water, and the presence of little green men on Mars are facts.

But in order to conclude that global warming is a true fact, you need to specify it better. "The earth was warmer at the end of 2008 than at the end of 2005" is false[1]; "the earth was warmer at the end of 2009 than at the end of 1999" is true; "the earth was warmer at the end of 2008 than at the end of 1988" depends on whether you're talking about monthly (true) or trailing-12-months (false) measurements. If you pick your date range right, you can get any truth-value you want.

[1] http://vortex.nsstc.uah.edu/public/msu/t2lt/tltglhmam_5.2

Re:Hal Lewis: My Resignation From The American Physical Society by jacquesm on Saturday October 09, 2010 @06:47PM (#1776092)
That's true, which makes this as difficult a thing as it is.
Re:Hal Lewis: My Resignation From The American Physical Society by lzw on Saturday October 09, 2010 @04:47PM (#1775834)
>Everybody is entitled to their opinions, but not everybody gets to have their own facts. >Global warming is not a theory, it is a fact,

It seems you feel you are entitled to your own facts. The fact of the matter is, the planet is getting cooler, in recent history, due to the abatement of the solar peak, despite CO2 increasing. These facts are easily verified and disprove your "global warming is fact" claim.

IF you go back far enough you can find that the earth has been warming since the last Ice age. If you go back further you can find that the earth has gone thru many of these cycles, including having CO2 rise as the temperature rises, even before there were human societies.

I believe you believe in this "fact" because it is a religion to you, and you believe in it like christians believe in jesus. Thus, you are the target of your own criticism of rejecting things out of hand.

IF you were being the least bit honest, you would recognize that global warming is a theory. And a very dubious one at that, with a long history of fabrication and dishonesty behind it, that originated in political, not scientific circles and which shows a clear political purpose.

The politicians have the motive- to gain extraordinary control over the economy. They have the opportunity- control over scientific funding and a clear mandate to defund projects that are not consistent with global warming theory. And a history of falsifications and other frauds coming to light.

This makes you a religious zealot who thinks that simply calling something a "fact" is some sort of an argument.

Re:Hal Lewis: My Resignation From The American Physical Society by tbrownaw on Saturday October 09, 2010 @09:13PM (#1776335)
> The fact of the matter is, the planet is getting cooler, in recent history

Link, please? I went looking, and couldn't find anything supporting this.

I believe you believe in this "fact" because it is a religion to you

Um, yeah...

Re:Hal Lewis: My Resignation From The American Physical Society by lotharbot on Saturday October 09, 2010 @01:39PM (#1775393)
> which ever of those is the case it is not going to hurt us one bit to know.

This seems to be the major contention being brought up in the letter. Not that GW is completely and purely a scam or should be completely written off (as you imply he is suggesting), but that the process for understanding and studying it has been corrupted by money and that attempts to put together a "topical group" to study it have been ignored for political reasons.

Re:Hal Lewis: My Resignation From The American Physical Society by jacquesm on Saturday October 09, 2010 @01:44PM (#1775408)
Yes, but that might easily be a case of sour grapes because it is not his proposal that got accepted.

I really got that vibe from the article, that this was as much about him not being part of the 'in' group as it was about a suddenly found set of principles over which to resign from this body.

Re:Hal Lewis: My Resignation From The American Physical Society by lzw on Saturday October 09, 2010 @04:14PM (#1775746)
You could characterize it that way, but realize also that if the set of the "in group" is people whose livelihoods are based on finding evidence for AGW theory and those in the "out" group are those who don't, then the set of people is the same as the set of theories.
Re:Hal Lewis: My Resignation From The American Physical Society by roberts_vc on Saturday October 09, 2010 @01:14PM (#1775346)
"Cue the global warming conspiracy theorists to spin this far and wide."

My first thought too. A GW Denialist - couldn't care less what he has to say, he obviously doesn't have the sense to stay outta the rain.

Re:Hal Lewis: My Resignation From The American Physical Society by pdonis on Saturday October 09, 2010 @01:30PM (#1775373)
I'm not sure where you're getting "denialist" from his article. He doesn't say anything about whether there is or isn't global warming, or whether humans are or are not causing at least a portion of it. His charge is that the APS, instead of fostering open debate, is stifling it. I do think he's too preoccupied with money as a motivation for why the stifling is being done; but his primary charge is basically that scientists aren't doing their due diligence the way they used to:

"As recently as thirty-five years ago, when I chaired the first APS study of a contentious social/scientific issue, The Reactor Safety Study, though there were zealots aplenty on the outside there was no hint of inordinate pressure on us as physicists. We were therefore able to produce what I believe was and is an honest appraisal of the situation at that time...How different it is now."

When I read the IPCC reports, for example, I find it hard to disagree with this assessment; even before ClimateGate we had plenty of evidence that what went into those reports was largely politically, not scientifically, determined. Note that this does not mean the IPCC reports are entirely wrong, nor does it mean that global warming will not be a problem. It means the reports don't make a good enough case for, say, emasculating the entire world economy in order to maybe, possibly, reduce the global temperature rise over the next century by a fraction of a degree Celsius.

Re:Hal Lewis: My Resignation From The American Physical Society by jdp23 on Saturday October 09, 2010 @03:14PM (#1775587)
well, he does use terms like "the global warming scam" and "the greatest and most successful pseudoscientific fraud I have seen in my long life as a physicist" which are typically associated with denialists.
Re:Hal Lewis: My Resignation From The American Physical Society by pdonis on Saturday October 09, 2010 @03:29PM (#1775628)
True, but I give him credit for using words a little more precisely than your average media hack. It's clear to me from the context that by "scam" and "fraud" he means not the simple claim that the climate is warming, nor even the claim that humans may be causing at least a portion of it, but the whole edifice that's been erected to drive certain political policies that are not justified by the state of the science, and to suppress any suggestion that those policies might not be justified.
Re:Hal Lewis: My Resignation From The American Physical Society by jdp23 on Saturday October 09, 2010 @03:46PM (#1775670)
agreed, the main tone of his article is somebody lamenting "scientists behaving badly" and remarking on the changes since the good old days. no idea whether or not he's a denialist, i was just trying to highlight that the language he uses could lead people to assume that.