In many cases, he has valid opinions, but just like in medicine, more opinions should be sought before making a final decision.
Certainly we'd all be happy to have jwz onboard our teams, but Joel holds him out as the one exception of a "good" duct-tape programmer. It's just really absurd. Joel's position seems to be "anyone that does not follow the dictates of the latest MEGA XTREME WATERFALL AGILE METHODOLOGY is going to do more damage than good", when really, like in almost everything else, the passing fads are merely empty promises hyped on to make consultants and specialists rich.
You may want to read jwz's response, I think it is fairly concise and good: http://jwz.livejournal.com/1096593.html
What's the point of my story? Perhaps duct tape isn't always the best solution, but there are certainly times where the application of duct tape (or zip ties) is an appropriate response, the trick is identifying when and where, and being willing and able to do it when it makes sense.
I ask you, in what other industry would doing shoddy workmanship be considered an insightful viewpoint? Would you be happy if you discovered you'd hired "The Duct Tape Plumber" to fix a leak in your house?
Furthermore, I've actually known real people like the ones Joel Spolsky idealizes: "He is the guy you want on your team building go-carts, because he has two favorite tools: duct tape and WD-40." Spolsky is wrong wrong wrong: you do NOT want this guy on your team. He's the guy who ruins bearings because he uses WD-40 instead of a real lubricant, the guy who spends 40 minutes crafting a duct tape solution rather than take a 20 minute drive to O'Reilly's to get the right part. I had a guy like this work on a truck I used to own; we accidently bought the wrong heater core but rather than get the right one, he figured out it could fit backwards if we cut the panels around it and routed the hoses around it in a loop, and then he covered it in duct tape. The problem is that it wasn't really air tight, so it was no good as a heater because it didn't force the air through. I had to redo it myself with the right part, and had to reattach all the panels he cut.