News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Heavy-handed security searches of hotel rooms at Defcon/B... by repsilat on Monday August 13, 2018 @05:15AM (#17748883)
> is has been < 12 months since

For clarification, do you mean that after more time

- the hotel will forget about the shooting,

- shootings will become less likely, or

- secret privacy invasions that people were never meant to know about will stop being such good PR.

I think maybe closest to the first? That we should be understanding in the short term around overreaction because those businesses have suffered trauma and just need time to get back to a normal state of mind.

Of those three reasons I have the most sympathy for the second, though still not a lot. Perhaps all of them can be phrased more even-handedly, though, and maybe there are better reasons why the passage of time might matter. I'm happy to listen.

> What did they expect?

I think they expected respect, privacy and professionalism from their hotel at their conference. They wanted to feel safe, not invaded and bullied.

This kind of thing will drive more people to Airbnb -- security is worse, but trust is higher.

Re:Heavy-handed security searches of hotel rooms at Defcon/B... by sky_rw on Monday August 13, 2018 @05:26AM (#17748937)
I'm sure Caesars Palace is far less concerned about driving a few people to Airbnb than the lawsuits/fallout from another mass casualty incident. It's in their best interest to be overly careful here, even if it does strike us as invasive and paranoid.
Re:Heavy-handed security searches of hotel rooms at Defcon/B... by netsharc on Monday August 13, 2018 @05:40AM (#17749003)
To me it seems moronic to have a procedure to prevent a rare incident, AFTER one has happened: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_swan_theory

Just like checking shoes before boarding a plane after 1 shoe bomber...

Or are they afraid of copycats?

Honestly they should just invest in a bit more tech. How about modifying their lifts to detect large amounts of metals, or explosives? (Well, there's your next security technology goldmine). But of course hiring muscles is cheaper, never mind that maybe party goers will stop coming to Vegas if they get harassed.

Re:Heavy-handed security searches of hotel rooms at Defcon/B... by antod on Monday August 13, 2018 @07:57AM (#17749408)
It seems pretty rational (even if quite cynical) to me. The covering your ass liability for a similar repeat of a black swan event must be way higher than it was the first time around.

You can't claim surprise or lack of precedent for the second time, and it really does look like negligence to the circling lawyers if you didn't react to it.

In risk management terms, the likelihood of a repeat might not have changed, but the consequence of a repeat sure has.

Re:Heavy-handed security searches of hotel rooms at Defcon/B... by secfirstmd on Monday August 13, 2018 @05:52AM (#17749039)
Your technocentrism approach to security is contradictory. On the one hand you say shoes shouldn't be checked with tech (even though there were many AQ/ISIS bomb makers trying to use the technique) and then you say modify lifts (at enourmous cost and dubious enhanced security - what about stairs? etc) to detect explosives.

Reality is that the searches of peoples stuff was a heavy handed and unclear policy that the hotels didn't make clear to the customer so that they could have an informed choice. However a Mark 1 eyeball is in this case probably the most effective choice for a security mitigation.

Re:Heavy-handed security searches of hotel rooms at Defcon/B... by viraptor on Monday August 13, 2018 @09:33AM (#17749912)
The slight difference is that a tech solution in the lift would actually apply to everybody. "Mark 1 eyeballs" very likely have a big bias regarding who needs checking.