It is a well established fact that the body makes a host of metabolic adjustments in response to changes in diet.
Food we eat is drained of nutrients and excreted. The excretions are less than the food, and the rest is absorbed into the body.
The other excretion we have is sweat, which is primarily salts and water.
The only avenue in which we can shed weight is by CO2 exhaled...
(I do not have a citation for this from a paper, but heard the same description from 2 different dieticians. I accepted this as fact.)
Losing weight to combat obesity and just generally being healthy to maintain your weight are two different situations. You take meds to address specific illnesses.
Need to lose weight? Calories in and out is probably 80% of the nutritional knowledge you need. Everything else is just psychology. What keeps you consistent? 5 small meals or one big one? Try em both. See what sticks. Simple. Not Easy, but simple.
But yes, in 100 years, I bet the obesity crisis will be another cooky documentary topic like the lobotomy hype, tobacco smoking and the treatment of ulcers with vacations instead of antibiotics.