News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Machine learning links brain connectivity patterns with p... by sandworm101 on Friday August 10, 2018 @12:49PM (#17734906)
The concept sounds perfectly acceptable and promising: documenting brain activity to aid in the diagnosis of mental illness, but this treads on some touchy issues. Specifically, what is and isn't considered "normal". The article notes that...

"Unlike other branches of modern medicine which use biologically-based tests of disease, psychiatry still relies on patient reports and physician observations".

That is true. But unlike other branches of medicine, psychiatry doesn't try to fix people that aren't struggling. We go to the doctor, who then tells us our BP is too high and we need to exercise more. We don't go to our psychiatrist for such checkups. A doctor knows what good and bad blood pressure look like, and will seek to move us from bad to good. Today, psychiatrists rarely ever examine, let alone treat, people until their mental state is negatively impacting their lives. They treat the clinical case. They don't go around telling people they are sick in the way medical doctors look at blood pressure. A brain scan, a "biologically-based test" opens the door to treating people who aren't yet a clinical case. I am sure that such scans would aid in the diagnosis and understanding of mental illness. But by expanding the diagnostic process, these scans would also open up a huge new market for the psychiatric treatment of non-clinical cases.

Re:Machine learning links brain connectivity patterns with p... by rifung on Friday August 10, 2018 @03:15PM (#17736020)
> But by expanding the diagnostic process, these scans would also open up a huge new market for the psychiatric treatment of non-clinical cases

But is that a bad thing? You are free to ignore their treatment suggestions just like with doctors. My doctor actually did tell me to see a therapist based on some test he had me take.

I suspect it would be better if we could prevent issues from arising in the first place but we don't understand enough to even know whether that's possible. Still, having better biological markers may make that possible no?

I can understand your concern but I like to think we can trust the medical community to make good judgment regarding the tradeoffs between invasive treatment and risk just as they already do.

Re:Machine learning links brain connectivity patterns with p... by felix_nagaand on Friday August 10, 2018 @01:28PM (#17735213)
Uhm. A large number of people, especially children are subjected to psychiatric treatment that they do not request. Courts routinely order treatment for pre- conviction defendants. Schools routinely send under performing or 'difficult'students to psychologists for treatment. These are non- consensual relationships and a clear violation of the code of ethics. These practices taint studies the victims are included in. These forced relationships breed hostility for the field and further isolate the very people supposedly 'getting helped' by these systems.
Re:Machine learning links brain connectivity patterns with p... by openasocket on Friday August 10, 2018 @02:32PM (#17735706)
Courts only order treatment for defendants pre-conviction if they are determined to be mentally incapable of standing trial. This is a very basic standard that simply requires that the defendant understands what a judge is, what a jury is, what the charges are, etc. Are you actually suggesting that the ethical thing to do is to try and potentially convict people too mentally ill to understand what is going on?

Also, I'm not aware of any public school, at least in the US, that sends students to psychologists for treatment. Schools don't even employ clinical psychologists or psychiatrists, and they can't require that a student go to a psychologist to remain at a school.

Re:Machine learning links brain connectivity patterns with p... by anonymfus on Friday August 10, 2018 @02:02PM (#17735495)
Disorders which patients don't want to treat are called egosyntonic. Examples: narcissism, anorexia, OCPD.
Re:Machine learning links brain connectivity patterns with p... by sandworm101 on Friday August 10, 2018 @02:50PM (#17735845)
That the patient, on their own, does not want to treat. But when those disorders negatively impact their lives they become a clinical case that can be treated. Either some legal proceeding causes them to opt into treatment (ie to keep/win custody of a child) or those around the patient insist they seek help.