News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Anne Frank Center asks Facebook to remove Holocaust denia... by UncleMeat on Friday August 10, 2018 @11:10AM (#17733969)
If we truly have a marketplace of ideas then shitty ideas should be able to fail in the market.

Denialism has already seen the light of day. Why must we enforce that it continues to see the light of day forever?

Re:Anne Frank Center asks Facebook to remove Holocaust denia... by krapp on Friday August 10, 2018 @11:40AM (#17734314)
>If we truly have a marketplace of ideas then shitty ideas should be able to fail in the market.

This implies that the marketplace of ideas optimizes for truth, which may not be the case.

>Why must we enforce that it continues to see the light of day forever?

Either it lives in the shadows forever, or the light of day forever, but it never goes away. With each succeeding generation as history becomes more abstract, denialism and revisionism becomes easier to justify and accept.

After all, why are there more people who believe the Moon landing was a hoax, now, than believed it when the event was recent, living memory? Because it's no more real to modern people than fiction.

The same effect applies to the Holocaust. History becomes myth, myth becomes farce. We forget the lessons of the past and we're doomed to repeat them. The only thing the suppression of shitty ideas does is make the wheel turn faster.

Re:Anne Frank Center asks Facebook to remove Holocaust denia... by dwaltrip on Friday August 10, 2018 @11:19AM (#17734078)
The usual argument is:

The process that decides what should be censored might easily be used to squash valuable and important minority dissent in the future.

Re:Anne Frank Center asks Facebook to remove Holocaust denia... by debacle on Friday August 10, 2018 @11:15AM (#17734026)
Because we are a great, enlightened, quickly broadening and quickly advancing society that is inoculated from the chattering of small minds.